Strategies to Improve Women’s Leadership Preparation for Early Career Global Health Professionals: Suggestions from Two Working Groups

Abstract

Background: Despite advances in gender equality, women still experience inequitable gaps in global health leadership, and barriers to women’s advancement as leaders in global health have been well described in the literature. In 2021, the Johns Hopkins Center for Global Health conducted two virtual working groups for emerging women leaders to share challenges and suggest solutions to advance women’s leadership in global health. In this paper, we present emerging themes from the working groups, provide a framework for the results, and discuss strategies for advancing women’s leadership in global health. Objectives: The objective of this paper is to synthesize and share the themes of the two working group sessions to provide strategies for improving women’s leadership training and opportunities in the field of global health. Methods: Approximately 182 women in the global health field participated in two virtual working group sessions hosted by the Johns Hopkins Center for Global Health using the Zoom platform. Participants were divided into virtual breakout rooms and discussed pre-assigned topics related to women’s leadership in global health. The participants then returned to share their ideas in a plenary session. Notes from the breakout rooms and transcripts from the plenary session were analyzed through a participatory and iterative thematic analysis approach. Findings: We found that the working group participants identified two overarching themes that were critical for emerging women leaders to find success in global health leadership. First, the acquisition of individual essential skills is necessary to advance in their careers. Second, the institutional environments should be setup to encourage and enable women to enter and succeed in leadership roles. The participants also shared suggestions for improving women’s leadership opportunities such as including the use of virtual technologies to increase training and networking opportunities, intersectionality in mentorship and sponsorship, combatting impostor syndrome, and the importance of work-life balance. Conclusions: Investing in women and their leadership potential has the promise to improve health and wealth at the individual, institutional, and community levels. This manuscript offers lessons and proposes solutions for increasing women’s leadership through improving individual level essential skills and fostering environments in which women leaders can emerge and thrive.

Factors Influencing the impact of nurse practitioners’ clinical autonomy: a self determining perspective

“…In the field of nursing, several barriers have hindered women from fully participating and advancing in their careers. These barriers include a lack of mentorship opportunities, workplace power imbalances, work–home responsibility imbalance, and gender bias (Harrison et al., 2022; Ryder et al., 2023). These barriers can occur at each stage of a woman's nursing career and can greatly impact their ability to advance professionally.…”

Abandoning Blue-Collar Management

“…15 The problem with this process is that studies clearly show that clinical excellence is a poor predictor for management success. [16][17][18][19] Clinical competence and skill, while vital to excellence in practice, do not translate into the requisite skill sets essential to effective management leadership. More often than not, even today, frontline nurse management roles are mostly learned "on-the-job," with periodic supporting continuing education as the developmental methodology for formal skill acquisition.…”

“…What has most often happened and still occurs today is that time and again the most skilled practitioners have been generally identified and selected to assume a variety of nursing leadership roles 15. The problem with this process is that studies clearly show that clinical excellence is a poor predictor for management success 16–19. Clinical competence and skill, while vital to excellence in practice, do not translate into the requisite skill sets essential to effective management leadership.…”

A Scoping Review on Resources, Tools, and Programs to Support Women’s Leadership in Global Health: What Is Available, What Works, and How Do We Know?

“…In our review we found that needs assessments were scarce. The EDGE program was one that documented findings from a working group that asked emerging women leaders in global health for an assessment of their needs for developing leadership skills [48]. Thoughtful and thorough assessments of leadership resources and interventions must occur more frequently to engage end users in designing programming that may affect them and to better design and deliver programs that will successfully empower women to learn and take on leadership roles in global health.…”