Stigma, inclusion and India’s Mental Healthcare Act 2017

Abstract

Purpose India’s Mental Healthcare Act 2017 provides a right to mental healthcare, revises admission and review procedures, effectively decriminalises suicide and has strong non-discrimination measures, among other provisions. The purpose of this paper is to examine Indian mental health professionals’ views of these changes as they relate to stigma and inclusion of the mentally ill. Design/methodology/approach The authors held nine focus groups in three Indian states, involving 61 mental health professionals including 56 psychiatrists. Findings Several themes relating to stigma and inclusion emerged: stigma is ubiquitous and results in social exclusion; stigma might be increased rather than remedied by certain regulations in the 2017 Act; stigma is not adequately dealt with in the legislation; stigma might discourage people from making “advance directives”; and there is a crucial relationship between stigma and education. Practical implications Implementation of India’s 2017 Act needs to be accompanied by adequate service resourcing and extensive education, including public education. This has commenced but needs substantial resources in order to fulfil the Act’s potential. Social implications India’s mental health legislation governs the mental healthcare of 1.3bn people, one sixth of the planet’s population; seeking to use law to diminish stigma and enhance inclusion in such a large country sets a strong example for other nations. Originality/value This is the first study of stigma and inclusion since India’s 2017 Act was commenced and it highlights both the potential and the challenges of such ambitious rights-based legislation.

Stigma towards dependent drinking and its role on caregiving burden: A qualitative study from Goa, India

“…And at that moment he [husband] craves for it. (Caregiver, 35) Collectively, these discussions indicated that there was a 'Problem of knowledge" within each of the interviewed groups.…”

“…It was just amongst the two of us. (Caregiver, 35) Nobody bothers… I have brought up my kids on my own. I still try to help anyone who asks me for help, but I don't get any help from these people.…”

“…In the evening when I saw him, he was drunk and was walking on the road. (Caregiver, 35) With little support and high caregiving burden, caregivers misattributed the alcohol-related behaviours of the man with dependence and despite all their efforts, felt neglected and undervalued.…”

Intimate partner violence against women with disability and associated mental health concerns: a cross-sectional survey in Mumbai, India

“…113 However, there were limitations in the development of both, 112 114 including the Mental Healthcare Act’s failure to sufficiently address stigma. 115 As for the PWDVA, India’s persistently high rates of domestic violence, which have grown during the COVID-19 pandemic, 116 are testament to the act’s failure to effect any real change in society. 117 118 This further demonstrates that, while policy can be an important tool for addressing attitudinal and environmental barriers, change will remain elusive without commitment to implementation supported by adequate funding and monitoring-accountability mechanisms.…”

India’s path towards better mental health in a pandemic

“…Recurrent themes surrounding stigmatizing portrayals of mental illness and electroconvulsive therapy in the Indian media hinder health-seeking behaviour. 46 Currently, no laws specifically direct or censor the distorted portrayal of mental illnesses in the media. In the long term, scientifically informed depictions are needed to promote de-stigmatization among the larger masses.…”