Sticky Floor, Broken Ladder, and Glass Ceiling: Gender and Racial Trends Among Neurosurgery Residents

Abstract

IntroductionDiversity and equity in academic medicine are critically important in improving healthcare standards and patient-related outcomes. Gender and racial disparities are some major challenges faced by the health system. This article reviews the gender and racial trends among residents of neurosurgery in the United States (US). MethodsWe retrospectively analyzed the data extracted from the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME)'s annual Data Resource Books from 2007 to 2019. ACGME cataloged gender as men and women and race/ethnicity was categorized as White/non-Hispanic, Asian or Pacific Island, Hispanic, Black/non-Hispanic, Native American/Alaskan, others, and unknown. Counts, proportions, relative, and absolute percentage changes were calculated to highlight trends in resident appointments over time and across the specialty of neurosurgery. ResultsThe number of female residents increased steadily from 10.6% in 2007 to 19.3% in 2019; with an absolute increase of 8.74%, a relative increase of 63.9%, and a simultaneous decrease in male residents. When averaged across the nine-year study period, 51% of the study sample was White (non-Hispanic), followed by Asian/Pacific Islanders at 15.2%. The representation of Hispanics was 4.3%, Black/African Americans were 4.5%, Native Americans/Alaskans were 0.2%, and others were 8% of the total study population. ConclusionOur study concludes that gender and racial disparity persist within the neurosurgery residency training programs in the US. Concrete efforts at all academic levels are needed to provide greater support for the females and for the careers of underrepresented minority (URM) trainees to ensure their increased representation in neurosurgery.

Advancing Diversity in Microbiology: A 55-Year Retrospective Analysis

“…One persistent issue that remains to be solved is the need for more women and URMs in decision-making roles within academia, industry, and science policymaking. Despite efforts to enhance recruitment and retention of women and URMs in science, the percentage of women decreases in more senior academic ranks, leading to what is commonly referred to as the sticky floor, broken ladder and glass ceiling; another name for this phenomenon is 'leaky pipeline' [43][44][45].…”

Diversity and Inclusion in Internal Medicine Training Programs: An Unfulfilled Dream

“…Public relations campaigns should be undertaken to highlight to health systems and other employers the underrepresentation of Black and Latino hospitalists [ 28 ]. Finally, we should focus on “building the pipeline,” which means increasing the number of people from one’s community who are nurtured academically and socially not only to pursue careers in science and medicine but also to be determined candidates and accomplished students, trainees, and physicians [ 29 , 30 ]. The findings of this study conclude that further research is needed into the composite etiologies leading to the declining representation of URM in residency programs of Internal Medicine.…”

Young women neurosurgeons and challenges – need for equity and diversity

“…In addition, another point of great relevance that should be reported is the discrepancy between races when evaluating the characteristics of neurosurgery residents. Analyzing physicians of the neurosurgery residency program in the US, for twelve years, Maqsood and collaborators ( 8 ) found that the largest contingent was white and caucasians. This difference points out the maintenance of structural racism and specialty elitization that, by associating itself with lack of representativity and social inequity, makes it almost impossible to others ethnic groups the interest in neurosurgery and the chance to build a solid career in the profession.…”