Crystallographic studies of insulin bound to receptor domains have defined the primary hormone-receptor interface. We investigated the role of Tyr B26 , a conserved aromatic residue at this interface. To probe the evolutionary basis for such conservation, we constructed 18 variants at B26. Surprisingly, nonaromatic polar or charged side chains (such as Glu, Ser, or ornithine (Orn)) conferred high activity, whereas the weakestbinding analogs contained Val, Ile, and Leu substitutions. Modeling of variant complexes suggested that the B26 side chains pack within a shallow depression at the solvent-exposed periphery of the interface. This interface would disfavor large aliphatic side chains. The analogs with highest activity exhibited reduced thermodynamic stability and heightened susceptibility to fibrillation. Perturbed self-assembly was also demonstrated in studies of the charged variants (Orn and Glu); indeed, the Glu B26 analog exhibited aberrant aggregation in either the presence or absence of zinc ions. Thus, although Tyr B26 is part of insulin's receptor-binding surface, our results suggest that its conservation has been enjoined by the aromatic ring's contributions to native stability and self-assembly. We envisage that such classical structural relationships reflect the implicit threat of toxic misfolding (rather than hormonal function at the receptor level) as a general evolutionary determinant of extant protein sequences.Insulin, a small globular protein critical to the maintenance of metabolic homeostasis (1), provides a classical model for studies of protein structure and self-assembly (2) with longstanding application to human therapeutics (3). Insulin contains two polypeptide chains, designated A and B, that are linked by two disulfide bridges (cystines A7-B7 and A20-B19); the A chain is further stabilized by an intrachain bridge (cystine A6-A11). In pancreatic -cells, insulin is stored within glucoseregulated secretory granules as zinc-coordinated hexamers (Fig. 1A). The hormone binds to a receptor-tyrosine kinase, designated the insulin receptor (IR). 5 The product of a single gene, the IR precursor is processed in the trans-Golgi network into its final disulfide-linked (␣) 2 homodimer conformation. The extracellular ␣ subunit contains hormone-binding elements, whereas the transmembrane  subunit contains the intracellular tyrosine kinase domain (4). Alternative splicing leads to two receptor isoforms, IR-A and IR-B (5). The threedimensional structure of the holoreceptor has been visualized only at low resolution (Ͼ20 Å), but these findings have been inconclusive (for review, see Ref. 6). How extracellular binding of insulin alters the structure of the receptor, leading in turn to activation of the intracellular tyrosine kinase domains, is a major unsolved problem (7).Dissection of the IR into discrete domains has enabled crystallographic analysis of its parts. The relevant structural biology is as follows. (i) Structures of the intracellular tyrosine kinase domains at 1.9 Å resolution have been o...