The Rh-catalyzed [2 + 2 + 2] cycloaddition of diynes and alkynes is a synthetically useful transformation that rapidly constructs complex scaffolds and has been used extensively for >70 years. Despite this utility, substrate reactivity issues persist, which are not mechanistically defined. Here, we provide a general predictive model for reactivity and turnover for this reaction. Contrary to the proposed electronic model, this is a predominately sterically driven process where productive turnover is proportional to alkyne steric parameters. This model allows for a priori prediction of catalyst loading, turnover, and reaction yield based on a simple assessment of the steric parameter (e.g., A-value) of the alkyne. The relationship is reciprocal, allowing A-values to be calculated from observed turnover.