Status Incongruity and Backlash against Female Legislators: How Legislative Speechmaking Benefits Men, but Harms Women

Abstract

The literature on nomination procedures and intra-party politics shows that engagement in personalized parliamentary activities helps legislators get re-elected and promoted in the party list. However, as a considerable body of scholarly work suggests, women in leadership positions who are perceived to disconfirm the well-known gender stereotypes by being “too assertive” and “agentic” in the workplace may suffer from what social psychologists call the “backlash effect” (i.e., facing economic and social sanctions). Integrating insights from the literatures on perceptions of female leadership and intra-party politics, we reveal the differential effect of legislative speechmaking on the career prospects of male and female members of parliament (MPs). Specifically, using an original dataset of over thirty-five thousand parliamentary speeches and the biographies of 2,140 MPs who served in the Grand National Assembly of Turkey between 1995 and 2011, we show that the well-documented positive effect of engagement in parliamentary activities on career prospects holds for male MPs, but not for their female counterparts. In fact, we found that female MPs who were active on the legislative floor were significantly less likely to get renominated and promoted in the party rank. These results imply that the challenges facing women in leadership positions go beyond electoral competition.

What Drives Women’s Substantive Representation in Muslim-Majority Countries? Lessons from Turkey

“…Male MPs, on the other hand, mostly focus on masculine issues such as commerce, defense, and government and public administration. These preliminary findings largely confirm the previous literature which argues that female legislators are more likely to focus on soft/feminine issues during their tenure in the parliament (Bäck, Debus, and Müller 2014; Yildirim 2020; Yildrım, Kocapınar, and Ecevit 2019a).…”

Gender and Party Discipline: Evidence from Africa’s Emerging Party Systems

“…Other empirical work outside of African parliaments also suggests that men legislators tend to be rewarded for agentic behavior, while women legislators tend to be punished. Analyzing thousands of parliamentary speeches in Turkey, Yildirim, Kocapnar, and Ecevit (2021) find that whereas men MPs who were active on the legislative floor were significantly more likely to get renominated and promoted in the party rank, women who were active in legislative speech making were less likely to be renominated and promoted. Similarly, research on ministerial selection in Sweden shows that women MPs who deviated from the party line during parliamentary speeches were less likely to be appointed to cabinet posts, whereas this pattern was not found among men (Baumann, Bäck, and Davidsson 2019).…”

The structured interview's resistance to gender discrimination under cognitive load

“…For example, according to role congruity theory, any conflict between the gender norms expected of women (e.g., to be communal) and the social norms expected of a gender‐typed job (e.g., an electrical powerline worker), can create challenges for women in these occupations. Women who display agentic traits that are stereotypical of their job position (rather than being stereotypical of women) are more likely to be criticized compared to men who display similar traits in the same situations (Brescoll, 2016; Gupta et al, 2018; Yildirim et al, 2019).…”