“…Obviously, there are a number of additional caveats in the comparisons -the different provenance of the samples, the types of demographic model considered, and the methods of analysis -but it would appear that the Y-chromosome microsatellite data are not compatible with either the autosomal microsatellite data or the SNP data, whereas the two autosomal data sets, despite substantial differences in the types of markers and modelling assumptions, appear to be compatible, generally suggesting weak evidence of population expansion. With respect to the details of the expansion models, it should be noted that the results in Beaumont (1999) and Reich et al (1999) suggest that inferences about population growth are relatively insensitive to the details of how population size changes, provided that the changes are monotonic. A further observation is that if data from geographically separated populations are pooled, ignoring the effects of population structure, as in the Y-chromosome data here, any signal of population growth will tend to be weakened (Reich et al, 1999;Wakeley et al, 2001;Ptak and Przeworski, 2002), yet the observation of population growth is very strong in this data set.…”