Statistical Inference for Odds Ratio of Two Proportions in Bilateral Correlated Data

Abstract

Bilateral correlated data frequently arise in medical clinical studies such as otolaryngology and ophthalmology. Based on an equal correlation coefficient model, this paper mainly aimed to investigate the statistical inference for the odds ratio of two proportions in bilateral correlated data, including not only three test procedures but also four confidence interval (CI) constructions. Through iterative algorithms, all unknown parameters are estimated in order to construct the likelihood ratio, score and Wald-type tests. Furthermore, the profile likelihood CI, score CI, and Wald-type CI are obtained by the bisection root-finding algorithm. We provided another Wald-type CI based on an asymptotic normality property. The performance of the proposed tests were investigated with regard to empirical type I error rate and power, and CI methods were compared in terms of mean coverage probability and mean interval width. Numerical simulations show that the score test is more robust, and has higher power than other tests. The score CI also has a shorter interval width, and its coverage probability is closer to 0.95. A real example is used to illustrate the proposed methods.