Statistical Analysis of Hubble/WFC3 Transit Spectroscopy of Extrasolar Planets

Abstract

Transmission spectroscopy provides a window to study exoplanetary atmospheres, but that window is fogged by clouds and hazes. Clouds and haze introduce a degeneracy between the strength of gaseous absorption features and planetary physical parameters such as abundances. One way to break that degeneracy is via statistical studies. We collect all published HST/WFC3 transit spectra for 1.1-1.65 μm water vapor absorption and perform a statistical study on potential correlations between the water absorption feature and planetary parameters. We fit the observed spectra with a template calculated for each planet using the Exo-transmit code. We express the magnitude of the water absorption in scale heights, thereby removing the known dependence on temperature, surface gravity, and mean molecular weight. We find that the absorption in scale heights has a positive baseline correlation with planetary equilibrium temperature; our hypothesis is that decreasing cloud condensation with increasing temperature is responsible for this baseline slope. However, the observed sample is also intrinsically degenerate in the sense that equilibrium temperature correlates with planetary mass. We compile the distribution of absorption in scale heights, and we find that this distribution is closer to log-normal than Gaussian. However, we also find that the distribution of equilibrium temperatures for the observed planets is similarly log-normal. This indicates that the absorption values are affected by observational bias, whereby observers have not yet targeted a sufficient sample of the hottest planets.

Exoplanetary Atmospheres: Key Insights, Challenges, and Prospects

“…One of the most surprising findings from the large ensemble of exoplanetary transmission spectra observed is the consistently low spectral amplitudes of H2O absorption features. In the tens of transmission spectra observed to date, for exoplanets over a wide range of masses and temperatures from cool super-Earths to ultra hot Jupiters, every single one has a H2O feature that is below two scale heights (86,255,58). This is in stark contrast to expectations, for which a saturated spectral feature in a transmission spectrum is expected to have an amplitude of ∼5-10 scale heights.…”

A Hubble PanCET Study of HAT-P-11b: A Cloudy Neptune with a Low Atmospheric Metallicity

“…Oberg et al 2011;Lambrechts et al 2014;Venturini et al 2016;Pudritz et al absorption signal in a majority of the close-in gas giant planets observed to date (e.g. Sing et al 2016;Fu et al 2017;Tsiaras et al 2018;Wakeford et al 2019). This problem is even more acute for the current sample of Neptune-sized planets, whose relatively small radii, high surface gravities, and low temperatures all combine to reduce the expected amplitude of atmospheric absorption as compared to their better-studied Jovian counterparts (e.g.…”

LRG-BEASTS: Transmission Spectroscopy and Retrieval Analysis of the Highly Inflated Saturn-mass Planet WASP-39b

“…Given the impact aerosols have on atmospheric characterization, it would be useful to know a priori whether a planet is likely to be clear or cloudy. For this reason, there have been a number of recent studies looking for arXiv:1908.02358v2 [astro-ph.EP] 17 Sep 2019 correlations between planetary parameters and the presence of clouds and hazes (Heng 2016;Sing et al 2016;Stevenson 2016;Crossfield & Kreidberg 2017;Fu et al 2017). While these studies have been conducted over relatively small sample sizes, there is growing evidence that hotter planets are more likely than cooler planets to be cloud free (e.g., WASP-121b, Evans et al 2018;KELT-9b, Hoeijmakers et al 2018.…”