Stakeholders' Views on E-cigarette Legislation: A Qualitative Study in Taiwan

Abstract

Objectives: Little is known about stakeholders' opinions on e-cigarette legislation in Taiwan. Our aim is to understand the perspectives of stakeholders regarding the current legal system and measures that could be included in future e-cigarette legislation in Taiwan.Materials and Methods: We conducted in-depth interviews with 14 Taiwanese stakeholders, using semi-structured questionnaires, either face-to-face or via telephone, in 2016–2017. All interviews were transcribed.Results: The current legal system is applied to e-cigarettes even though it does not mention them specifically, this system carries risks and faces challenges from anti-tobacco and vaper groups. Some weaknesses in the current legislative framework were noted, including the facts that e-cigarettes are sold without government approval, that there are no manufacturing standards, no inspections or monitoring, and no regulations for usage or advertising. There was wide acceptance among stakeholders that e-cigarettes should be better regulated, particularly e-cigarettes containing nicotine. Most interviewees agreed that there is a need to restrict e-cigarette use by teenagers and in public places where tobacco smoking is prohibited. Most interviewees also would like to restrict marketing, ban sales in vending machines, via mail order, and over the internet; label content and nicotine levels; and introduce health warnings and taxation.Conclusions: Almost all interviewees agreed that there is a need for a specific legal framework for e-cigarettes in Taiwan, and that e-cigarettes should be regulated in the same way as combustible cigarettes.

E-Cigarette Markets and Policy Responses in Southeast Asia: A Scoping Review

“…Only e-cigarettes that meet Pharmaceutical Affairs Act standards for medicines or medical devices can receive approval for import and sale in Taiwan. 105 In May 2020, Taiwan proposed to add a category for 'cigarette-like products' to its tobacco legislation to ban their import, sale, use and advertising. 106 Singapore's e-cigarette policy, which also bans e-cigarette purchase and possession, is the strictest in Southeast Asia.…”

The risk profile of electronic nicotine delivery systems, compared to traditional cigarettes, on oral disease: a review

“…In the field of stomatology, tobacco use is considered a risk factor for periodontal disease, implant-related disease, mucosal disease, and oral cancers ( 18 – 21 ). However, the consensus on the effects of ENDS on oral health needs to be further strengthened ( 22 ). Studies have shown that these devices still have harmful effects on the respiratory ( 23 , 24 ), nervous ( 25 , 26 ), reproductive ( 27 , 28 ), and digestive systems ( 29 ), and they should be considered as carcinogenic factors due to their nicotine content and other additives ( 30 – 32 ).…”