Spillovers from Online Engagement: How a Newspaper Subscriber’s Activation of Digital Paywall Access Affects Her Retention and Subscription Revenue

Abstract

Newspapers are increasingly reliant on subscription revenue as advertising spend shifts to online platforms. Many newspapers have implemented paywalls in an attempt to boost subscription revenue. We study whether and how paywalls can help newspapers boost subscription revenue by retaining existing subscribers. Most major newspapers offer free access to paywalled content to subscribers to the print edition, which may help the newspaper retain subscribers by making their subscriptions more valuable. We leverage variation in whether and when existing subscribers activated access to the paywall of a top 30 North American newspaper. Our identification strategy accounts for self-selection in subscribers’ decisions to activate paywall access. We find that a subscriber’s activation of digital access decreases the risk of her canceling her subscription by about 31% and increases her subscription revenue by 7%–12%. In other words, digital activation improves subscriber retention and the associated subscription revenue. This suggests a crosschannel spillover in which the online product (the paywalled website) increases customers’ valuation for the offline product (the printed newspaper). Our results have implications not only for the newspaper industry but also for firms in other industries that offer subscribers to one product free or subsidized access to a complementary product. This paper was accepted by Kartik Hosanagar, information systems.

The effects of surge pricing on driver behavior in the ride‐sharing market: Evidence from a quasi‐experiment

“…Owing to these two advantages, we use the causal forest algorithm to estimate the causal impact of surge pricing. Similar methods have been adopted by several recent studies (Cui & Davis, 2019; Guo et al, 2021; Iyengar et al, 2020; Pattabhiramaiah et al, 2021). We provide a review of the causal forest algorithm, how we construct the outcome variables, and how we implement the causal forest with a DiD design in our empirical setting in Appendix .…”

The Effectiveness of Membership-Based Free Shipping: An Empirical Investigation of Consumers’ Purchase Behaviors and Revenue Contribution

“…We adopt a linear probability DiD model (Pattabhiramaiah, Overby, and Xu 2021) with the same identification strategy as the main model, that is, a stacked specification with matching and control function approach, to capture the effect of MFS on customer retention: The parameter of Enroll it captures the treatment effect of MFS on retention. Table 7 shows that MFS enrollment has a significant effect on customer retention.…”

“…It suggests that without controlling for the selection on unobservables, the estimates could be biased upward. Thirdly, we also ran a classic leads–lags DiD model (Pattabhiramaiah, Overby, and Xu 2021; Xu et al 2017). The specification is similar to the specification shown in Equation 2a, except that we replaced αEnroll­ it with false∑ τ = − 12 − 2 0.2em ρ τ Enrol normall it + τ + false∑ τ = 1 12 0.2em ρ τ Enrol normall it + τ.…”

“…The specification is similar to the specification shown in Equation 2a, except that we replaced αEnroll­ it with false∑ τ = − 12 − 2 0.2em ρ τ Enrol normall it + τ + false∑ τ = 1 12 0.2em ρ τ Enrol normall it + τ. We use the τ = −1 term as a baseline to avoid the dummy variable trap (Pattabhiramaiah, Overby, and Xu 2021). Figure W3 of Web Appendix A presents the results of the treatment effects of each preenrollment and postenrollment month.…”

Scarcity-driven monetization of digital content

“…Recognizing the importance of preserving the print subscriber base, to the extent possible, most newspapers in the United States now bundle free access to digital newspapers with print subscriptions. While it is well-known that consumers rarely take full advantage of products especially when they are offered for free (Shampanier et al, 2007 ), bundling free access to digital news with print subscriptions has been shown to provide a tangible subscriber retention benefit for publishers (Pattabhiramaiah et al, 2022 ). In fact, print subscribers, who avail of such unlimited (free) access to digital news, end up delaying their subscription termination decisions, thereby contributing 7–12% higher revenues for newspapers.…”