Spatiotemporal Gait Patterns During Overt and Covert Evaluation in Patients With Parkinson’s Disease and Healthy Subjects: Is There a Hawthorne Effect?

Abstract

Parkinson's disease (PD) and aging lead to gait impairments. Some of the disturbances of gait are focused on step length, cadence, and temporal variability of gait cycle. Under experimental conditions gait can be overtly evaluated, but patients with PD are prone to expectancy effects; thus it seems relevant to determine if such evaluation truly reflects the spontaneous gait pattern in such patients, and also in healthy subjects. Thirty subjects (15 subjects with PD and 15 healthy control subjects) were asked to walk using their natural, preferred gait pattern. In half of the trials subjects were made aware that they were being evaluated (overt evaluation), while in the rest of the trials the evaluation was performed covertly (covert evaluation). During covert evaluation the gait pattern was modified in all groups. Gait speed was significantly increased (P = .022); step cadence and average step length were also significantly modified, the average step length increased (P = .002) and the cadence was reduced (P ≤ .001). Stride cycle time variability was unchanged significantly (P = .084). These changes were not significantly different compared between elderly and young healthy controls either. Due to the small sample size, a note of caution is in order; however, the significant results suggest that covert evaluation of gait might be considered to complement experimental evaluations of gait.

Inertial Sensors to Assess Gait Quality in Patients with Neurological Disorders: A Systematic Review of Technical and Analytical Challenges

“…Ambulatory assessment is more representative of people’s gait. Indeed, the environment with ILG is physiological; hours of walking at different times of day can be recorded, which is key to valid interpretation of pattern and rhythm variability parameters that assess gait at a macro-level (Robles-García et al, 2015); and the putative “white-coat” syndrome (Andrzejewski et al, 2016) is avoided. Nevertheless, ambulatory data extraction and analysis entail great challenges because various algorithms have been developed for controlled testing, and their validity in this uncontrolled environment is questioned.…”

Physical Activity Monitoring in Patients with Neurological Disorders: A Review of Novel Body-Worn Devices

“…Furthermore, utilising wearable activity monitors permits continuous patient monitoring by allowing data collection in the patient's own home [15]. These out-of-clinic data may provide a more accurate representation of the patient's ability, as some patients perform better in the clinical environment when under the observation of a clinician [16], while others perform better in the familiar environment of their own home. This approach also has the potential to reduce the burden on both the patient and the clinical site by decreasing the utilisation of valuable resources.…”

A model of free-living gait: A factor analysis in Parkinson’s disease

“…BWM allow for prolonged data capture which is essential for fluctuating pathologies such as Parkinson's disease (PD). In addition, data can be collected in habitual environments reducing the influence of Hawthorne effect [9].…”