Temperature extremes significantly contribute to climate change; therefore, the analysis of temperature extremes is essential in detecting and attributing climate change. The present study aims to analyze the spatiotemporal variations in the temperature extremes over India, using 0.25° × 0.25° high-resolution Sheffield temperature gridded dataset for a period of 62 years (1951–2012). In addition, the spatial distribution, statistical relation and trend pattern of Sheffield’s temperature dataset is compared with 1°×1°, gridded temperature dataset of Indian Meteorological Department (IMD). The mean of temperature indices show nearly similar spatial distribution in both datasets; however trend pattern of extreme indices show significant differences over different homogeneous temperature regions of India. There is mostly disagreement between the two datasets, for trend patterns of extreme indices at different homogeneous regions, but few grids show reasonable agreement for similar trend pattern. Both datasets reported a significant decreasing trend in TX10p (amount of cool days) and TN10p (amount of cold nights) at maximum grids for the 1951–2012 period. In addition, a significant increasing trend in TX90p (amount of hot days) and WSDI (warm spell duration indicator) at maximum grids during post-1981 and 1951–2012 is observed in both datasets. A comprehensive insight into different characteristics (spatial distribution, statistical relation and trend patterns) of Sheffield’s temperature dataset will help in understanding the applicability of Sheffield temperature dataset for climate modeling and prediction studies over India.