Spatial Factors Influence Arithmetic Performance: The Case of the Minus Sign

Abstract

Spatial features of mathematical equations may influence how people solve and interpret those equations. This study examined whether manipulations of spatial features affected how participants solved and interpreted equations involving the minus sign. Undergraduate participants (N = 91) solved multioperation arithmetic equations involving addition, subtraction, and multiplication (e.g., 25 - 3 + 2 × 5 = __). We varied the spacing of the final three operands and the position of the first operator relative to the adjacent operands. Participants also generated a story problem to correspond with a given equation. We evaluated the procedures that participants used in solving the equations by analysing both their solutions and their written work. Both close spacing of the final three operands and position of the first operation sign influenced the procedures that participants used. Both of the spatial manipulations also influenced participants' interpretations of the conceptual structure of the equations, as revealed in the story problems that they generated. These results have implications for understanding how people process mathematical symbols and for mathematics education.

Perceptual support promotes strategy generation: Evidence from equation solving

“…Our findings also add to the growing body of work on perceptual processes in students’ interpretations of mathematical inscriptions (e.g., Jiang et al ., ; Landy & Goldstone, ,,; Massey, Kellman, Roth, & Burke, ). Specifically, they converge with other research suggesting that colour can be an effective way to guide learners’ attention to key features of instructional materials (Kalyuga, Chandler, & Sweller, ; Ozcelik, Karakus, Kursun, & Cagiltay, ; Ozcelik et al ., ).…”

“…Several studies have suggested that perceptual support for accurate encoding, even without direct instruction about what to encode, can facilitate learning and problem solving (e.g., DeLoache, ; Jamet, Gavota, & Quaireau, ; Joh & Spivey, ). Moreover, misleading perceptual cues can also hinder people's problem solving (Jiang, Cooper, & Alibali, ; Landy & Goldstone, ). These lines of work highlight the importance of implicit, perceptual factors in guiding problem encoding.…”

Spacing and Presentation Modes Affect the Unit-Decade Compatibility Effect During Number Comparison

“…Spacing effects on equations suggest that it is harder to solve mathematical problems if the operands are spaced closer together than if they are spaced farther apart (Jiang, Cooper, & Alibali, 2014; Kirshner, 1989). Landy and Goldstone (2007a, 2007b, 2010) extended these works and varied the spacing according to the syntactic structure of the equations.…”

How Mental Rotation Skills Influence Children’s Arithmetic Skills

“…Consequently, the result of the evaluation of arithmetic skills can be affected by visuo-spatial skills, even if there is not a conceptual link between both. Jiang, Cooper, and Alibali (2014) reported that spatial features of mathematical equations may influence how people solve and interpret them.…”