There is debate as to whether the neurocognitive changes associated with HIV infection represent an acceleration of the typical aging process or more simply reflect a greater accentuated risk for age-related declines. We aimed to determine whether accelerated neurocognitive aging is observable in a sample of older HIV-infected individuals compared to age-matched seronegatives and older-old (i.e., aged ≥ 65) seronegative adults. Participants in a cross-sectional design included 48 HIV-seronegative (O−) and 40 HIV-positive (O+) participants between the ages of 50–65 (mean ages = 55 and 56, respectively) and 40 HIV-seronegative participants aged ≥ 65 (OO−; mean age = 74) who were comparable for other demographics. All participants were administered a brief neurocognitive battery of attention, episodic memory, speeded executive functions, and confrontation naming (i.e., Boston Naming Test). The O+ group performed more poorly than the O− group (i.e., accentuated aging), but not differently from the OO− on digit span and initial recall of a supraspan word list, consistent with an accelerating aging profile. However, the O+ group’s performance was comparable to the O− group on all other neurocognitive tests (ps > .05). These data partially support a model of accelerated neurocognitive aging in HIV-infection, which was observed in the domain of auditory verbal attention, but not in the areas of memory, language, or speeded executive functions. Future studies should examine whether HIV-infected adults over 65 evidence accelerated aging in downstream neurocognitive domains and subsequent everyday functioning outcomes.