South Asian women, psychological distress and self-harm: lessons for primary care trusts

Abstract

The present paper reports an investigation of the self-reported needs of South Asian women suffering distress and mental health problems which may lead to self-harm and suicide, and uses the data to define indicators of good practice for primary care. The design was a qualitative study using focus group discussion. Four focus groups of South Asian women (using existing women's groups in Manchester, UK) formed the setting for this study. Each focus group was facilitated by one of the authors, and the discussions occurred in Urdu, English and Punjabi. An interview guide was used, although the direction of the discussions followed the women's agenda. Notes were taken during the focus group discussions. Analysis of notes to define themes and emergence of framework was carried out. The data were analysed according to the principles of framework analysis. A range of systemic issues were described by respondents including: social, political and economic pressures; domestic violence; poverty; language problems; family and children's issues; and health. These experiences were reinforced by an extremely efficient community grapevine and were evident in described experiences such as: racism and stereotyping of Asian women; Asian communities and Islam; and the concept of izzat (honour) in Asian family life, which was seen as a major influence in the lives of Asian women. These experiences were thought to result in mental distress, which was described in a variety of ways by the women. The women saw self-harm as a usable coping strategy to deal with their distress. Perceived barriers to services were described by the women. Services tended to be accessed only at a point of desperation, rather than prior to crisis points. This indicated the need for services to be able to respond rapidly when Asian women did ask for help. Whilst the present paper describes a local study, thus limiting its generalisability, the use of such work in commissioning local health and social services is outlined. A number of indicators for good practice were drawn up in relation to addressing systemic issues in service provision using these findings. Such indicators will be of use by primary care trusts in developing, commissioning and monitoring services for this patient group.

Evaluation of Honour Killings in Turkey

“…Honour killings are widespread in the societies where patriarchal family type and strong family ties are maintained [3,18,19]. The socio-cultural phenomenon called "tribe"…”

Increasing equity of access to high-quality mental health services in primary care: a mixed-methods study

“…Engagement and communication are inherently problematic in the cases of adolescents with eating disorders 28 and women from ethnic minorities. 29 These groups also share a crucial set of problems with regard to health literacy, that is, the capacity to obtain, interpret and understand health information and services in ways that are health enhancing. 30 Health literacy is in part related to lack of educational attainment, but importantly it is also about the stigma associated with seeking help for mental health problems.…”

“…28 Women from ethnic minorities tend to seek professional care only when in crisis. 29 Homeless people perceive reluctance to treat on the part of service providers. l Professional contexts.…”

“…Women from South Asian communities could be cut off from their familial and social networks if they failed to conform to the rules and roles of those cultures or the expectations of their partner or family. 29,218 when the inability to adequately perform social roles is legitimated by the sick role. Social problems relate to changes in, diminution of or incapacity to perform -or to be seen to perform -previous social roles that formed their identity.…”

Cultural Barriers to the Disclosure of Child Sexual Abuse in Asian Communities: Listening to What Women Say

“…The women interviewed by Chew-Graham et al (2002) also emphasised the extent to which the experience of migration may heighten difficulties by adding to competition between families and to pressures to be seen to be 'doing well' in the eyes of relatives in Pakistan. They noted, in particular, that the 'good' behaviour of women is seen as adding to status and prestige.…”