South Africa as an emerging power: from label to ‘status consistency’?

Abstract

South Africa proudly wears the label 'emerging power', with its membership of the BRICS and G20 probably the most visible signs of this conferred status. This paper explores the concept of the emerging powers within the context of current global power shifts and locates South Africa within this group. It discusses the criteria for and characteristics of emerging powers, and then turns to some of the constraints and challenges faced by these states. Specific attention is paid to the 'how' of these states' recognition and inclusion in global institutions and to the impact of domestic conditions and regional politics on their positions, focusing particularly on South Africa. It concludes that these factors will continue to challenge South Africa's ability to rise above the semblance of importance conferred by its inclusion in the category of emerging powers to a position in which it exercises this status to its own advantage, including its idealistic objectives of promoting greater global equality and recognition for Africa and the global South. Although other emerging powers face similar challenges, South Africa's domestic constraints and related lack of regional and global reach, politically and economically, threatens its 'status consistency' as an emerging power

Nigeria’s Soft Power Sources: Between Potential and Illusion?

“…In what platforms is Nigeria's cultural attraction located? The answer lies in identifying the cultural elements within the Nigerian society that highlight positive perception of its global popularity and admiration (Rapid Growth Markets Soft Power 8 As some scholars argue, South Africa regional prominence as an emerging power and a putative hegemony in the continent has been due largely to its superior soft power strength along with its traditional hard power competences (see Smith 2012, Sidiropoulos 2014, Ogunnubi and Isike 2015, Schoeman 2015. 9 We must state at the outset that President Obasanjo's record from 1999 to 2007 may be disputed as an attractive element of Nigeria's soft power.…”

South Africa in Global Development Fora: Cooperation and Contestation

“…Until the mid-2000s, South Africa played a bridge-building role quite successfully. As a middle-sized developing country, South Africa's global influence can only be advanced through assiduous relationship-building across dividing lines around common interests (Schoeman 2015). That role was less in evidence in the Jacob Zuma period (Masters 2017).…”

Currencies, Constraints and Contradictions of South Africa’s Soft Power

“…In order to have a meaningful impact in the global arena, a state has to put its own house in order. Thus, as the African National Congress (ANC) government remains in the grip of these challenges, Pretoria’s role in the international arena diminishes because significant human and material resources are channelled to address these domestic issues (Schoeman, 2015). It is logical that these problems distract Pretoria from its international engagements.…”

“…More than two decades into democracy, it appears that inequality is increasing. For instance, between 1996 and 2012, the ratio of white per capita income to that of the other races increased from 3.9: 1 to 4.5:1 (Schoeman, 2015). Despite the fact that 16 million poor South Africans benefit from social grants, the rate of inequality remains stagnant at best, if not wider (Keeton, 2014).…”