Sources of error in emergency ultrasonography

Abstract

BackgroundTo evaluate the common sources of diagnostic errors in emergency ultrasonography.MethodsThe authors performed a Medline search using PubMed (National Library of Medicine, Bethesda, Maryland) for original research and review publications examining the common sources of errors in diagnosis with specific reference to emergency ultrasonography. The search design utilized different association of the following terms : (1) emergency ultrasonography, (2) error, (3) malpractice and (4) medical negligence. This review was restricted to human studies and to English-language literature. Four authors reviewed all the titles and subsequent the abstract of 171 articles that appeared appropriate. Other articles were recognized by reviewing the reference lists of significant papers. Finally, the full text of 48 selected articles was reviewed.ResultsSeveral studies indicate that the etiology of error in emergency ultrasonography is multi-factorial. Common sources of error in emergency ultrasonography are: lack of attention to the clinical history and examination, lack of communication with the patient, lack of knowledge of the technical equipment, use of inappropriate probes, inadequate optimization of the images, failure of perception, lack of knowledge of the possible differential diagnoses, over-estimation of one’s own skill, failure to suggest further ultrasound examinations or other imaging techniques.ConclusionsTo reduce errors in interpretation of ultrasonographic findings, the sonographer needs to be aware of the limitations of ultrasonography in the emergency setting, and the similarities in the appearances of various physiological and pathological processes. Adequate clinical informations are essential. Diagnostic errors should be considered not as signs of failure, but as learning opportunities.

Point-of-care ultrasound in management of gallstone ileus – a case report

“…Moreover, US is safe, accessible, cheap, repeatable, noninvasive, dynamic, in real-time examination. US is highly operator and equipment dependent [18][19][20] but newer techniques are now available to improve the accuracy of the diagnosis.…”

Aging of the venous valves as a new risk factor for venous thrombosis in the elderly: the BATAVIA study

“…Some aspects of our study warrant comment. First, quality of ultrasonography examinations is directly related to operator skill, training, and experience . To minimize inter‐individual bias all examinations were performed by one operator (AK).…”

Only credentialed physicians should be performing ultrasound in emergency department: Yes

“…Additionally, a consultant radiologist will generally not provide a specialist report on the images created. The risk of inaccurate diagnosis based on novice POCUS is therefore greater than other imaging studies …”