Sounds as properties

Abstract

Leddington has recently put forward a new version of the idea that sounds are properties. Whereas other ‘property views’ take material objects to be the bearers of sounds (the sound of a bell being struck is a property instantiated by the bell itself), on Leddington's view sounds are borne by the source events in which these objects are participating (the sound of a bell being struck is a property instantiated by the striking event). In this paper, I argue that the case for events as the bearers of sound properties rather than objects is, at best, ambiguous, and that there are good reasons for wanting to include objects amongst the things we hear. I put forward a new account on which sounds are temporally extended properties of objects. This approach, I argue, not only retains the advantages of Leddington's view, but also allows for the audibility of both objects and events.

La cognición auditiva. Especificidad modal y perplejidad semántico-definicional

“…En años recientes, la discusión en la filosofía del sonido ha puesto de relieve el problema de la relación entre los sonidos con sus fuentes (O'Callaghan, 2011;Casati, Di Bona, Dokic, 2013;Leddington, 2019;Young, 2021). Inicialmente, el acercamiento estándar sugiere que los sonidos están relacionados causalmente con las fuentes que las producen.…”