Sound Water Masking to Match a Waterfront Soundscape with the Users’ Expectations: The Case Study of the Seafront in Naples, Italy

Abstract

In the last decades, the soundscape approach has attracted the attention of architects and urban planners, leading them to incorporate the acoustic features into the enjoyment of their creations. One of the key aspects for an appreciated urban environment is to match the expectations of the users. In this study, the matching of the waterfront soundscape with the users’ expectations is evaluated by laboratory tests using semantic differential scales applied to reproduced virtual scenarios obtained adding different water sound pressure levels (SPLs) to the original in-situ setting. The tests were carried out by an immersive virtual reality (IVR) device, using 360° videos and spatial audio recorded in two sites of the waterfront in Naples, Italy. The scenarios were presented to the participants according to three experimental protocols, namely audio-only (A), video-only (V), and simultaneous audio-video (AV) reproduction. The examined different acoustic scenarios were the original one recorded in situ and others obtained adding seawater sounds at SPL increments of 5 dB. The results show that all the scenarios with water sounds added are rated more pleasant than the original one for the audio-only scenario. When video and audio are displayed simultaneously, two scenarios are more pleasant than the original one, likely because there is a need for coherence between the water sound SPL heard and the visible noise sources. Sounds coherent with the type of shore show a higher matching with expectations and pleasantness appraisals, rather than those that are uncoherent with the layout scenario.

COVID-19 and lockdown schooling: how digital learning environments influence semantic structures and sustainability knowledge

“…SDs have been used to assess attitudes toward certain topics or objects in a variety of research disciplines, such as social studies, economics, marketing, geology, and architecture [43][44][45][46][47][48][49]. It is regarded as an effective psychological tool for measuring multidimensional traits such as personality, attitude, or communication [50].…”

A study on the influence of dominant sound sources on users’ emotional perception in a pediatric dentistry clinic

“…Additionally, indoor spaces may be affected by both external and internal sound sources. Therefore, a suitable combination of indoor and outdoor sound sources can be made based on perceptual needs ( Torresin et al, 2020b ); for instance, creating sounds of water outdoors as a sound mask ( Puyana-Romero et al, 2021 ).…”

Characteristics and Trends of Urban Waterfront Human Settlements Based on CiteSpace

“…It is not only an important part of urban human settlement but also an area with both natural landscape and artificial scenery [1] . The research on urban waterfront human settlements started around 2010 and this type of research has increased locally and abroad ever since [2][3][4][5][6] . In particular, the ecological environment has been increasingly emphasized, focusing on the harmonious coexistence between man and nature.…”