The role of the teacher, specifically teacher craft, is central to engaging students in effective reading instruction. However, the science of reading has revealed that the content taught is also important to reading acquisition. Although the science of reading was aggregated some two decades ago to result in what became known as the five big pillars, it has not been fully incorporated into instructional practice. Subsequent research has continued to inform and strengthen what we understand about reading, and new energy has now emerged to bring the science of reading fully into practice. However, the science of reading and teacher craft are each insufficient without the other. In this article, we discuss the art of teaching and advocate that it must be given serious consideration if the science of reading is to be adopted en masse by teachers. We also discuss several reading strategies and their role in effective reading instruction and the art of teaching.It is the supreme art of the teacher to awaken joy in creative expression and knowledge. (Albert Einstein) A s Einstein's quote suggests, teachers can have tremendous influence on the academic and creative development of their students, to which we add their reading development. Literacy instruction is not only teaching the skills, strategies, and content of science-based teaching but also recognizing that teachers must be flexible and adaptive in their daily decision making and interaction with students to meet their literacy needs. Thus, the art of teaching involves professional judgments and adaptations to content delivery that teachers make to their reading instruction to ensure student success (Scales et al., 2018). We firmly stand on the science of reading (SOR) as it has established components that are critical to students' successful reading acquisition. Whereas Seidenberg, Cooper Borkenhagen, and Kearns (2020) argued that the SOR and teaching practice are two different entities, we maintain that the SOR has established the importance of the art of teaching reading. Further, we propose that the SOR and teacher craft are individually insufficient for effective reading instruction but, when properly blended, become powerful allies that lead to improved reading outcomes for all students.