Gromov, in his seminal 1989 paper on the Oka principle, introduced the notion of an elliptic manifold and proved that every continuous map from a Stein manifold to an elliptic manifold is homotopic to a holomorphic map. We show that a much stronger Oka principle holds in the special case of maps from certain open Riemann surfaces called circular domains into C× C * , namely that every continuous map is homotopic to a proper holomorphic embedding. An important ingredient is a generalisation to C × C * of recent results of Wold and Forstnerič on the long-standing problem of properly embedding open Riemann surfaces into C 2 , with an additional result on the homotopy class of the embeddings. We also give a complete solution to a question that arises naturally in Lárusson's holomorphic homotopy theory, of the existence of acyclic embeddings of Riemann surfaces with abelian fundamental group into 2-dimensional elliptic Stein manifolds.