Solving and Testing for Regressor-Error (in)Dependence When no Instrumental Variables are Available: With New Evidence for the Effect of Education on Income

Abstract

This paper has two main contributions. Firstly, we introduce a new approach, the latent instrumental variables (LIV) method, to estimate regression coefficients consistently in a simple linear regression model where regressor-error correlations (endogeneity) are likely to be present. The LIV method utilizes a discrete latent variable model that accounts for dependencies between regressors and the error term. As a result, additional ‘valid’ observed instrumental variables are not required. Furthermore, we propose a specification test based on Hausman (1978) to test for these regressor-error correlations. A simulation study demonstrates that the LIV method yields consistent estimates and the proposed test-statistic has reasonable power over a wide range of regressor-error correlations and several distributions of the instruments. Secondly, the LIV method is used to re-visit the relationship between education and income based on previously published data. Data from three studies are re-analyzed. We examine the effect of education on income, where the variable ‘education’ is potentially endogenous due to omitted ‘ability’ or other causes. In all three applications, we find an upward bias in the OLS estimates of approximately 7%. Our conclusions agree closely with recent results obtained in studies with twins that find an upward bias in OLS of about 10% (Card, 1999). We also show that for each of the three datasets the classical IV estimates for the return to education point to biases in OLS that are not consistent in terms of size and magnitude. Our conclusion is that LIV estimates are preferable to the classical IV estimates in understanding the effects of education on income. Copyright Springer Science + Business Media, Inc. 2005instrumental variables, latent instruments, testing for endogeneity, mixture models, identifiability, estimating the return to education,

Aggregation Bias in Sponsored Search Data: The Curse and the Cure

“…Ghose and Yang (2009) (Ebbes et al, 2005), which has been used by Rutz and Trusov (2011) and Rutz et al (2012) to account for position endogeneity. The LIV framework uses a likelihood based approach, which can be easily integrated with the HB model proposed earlier, and can be estimated using the MCMC estimator.…”

Frugal IV alternatives to identify the parameter for an endogenous regressor

“…We discuss three methods that can potentially be used as an alternative to classical IV when no or only weak instruments are available: (1) the HM method (Erickson and Whited, 2002;Lewbel, 1997); (2) the IH estimator (Rigobon, 2003;Hogan and Rigobon, 2003); and (3) the LIV method (Ebbes et al, 2005). We use the structural model given in (1), in which we are primarily interested in the effect of x and x 2 on y.…”

Mode Choice Model for Public Transport with Categorized Latent Variables

“…The initial research on latent variables can be traced back to Spearman [9] that conducted factor analysis for human intelligence test. Latent variables were widely applied in many fields, such as social sciences [10,11], psychology [12,13], and market and economics research [14,15].…”