“…Disko, Greenland [ Yde et al ., ], Rhone Glacier, Switzerland [ Hosein et al ., ], South Cascade Glacier, USA [ Reynolds and Johnson , ], Gangorti, Himalaya [ Singh et al ., ], and Satopanth, Himalaya [ Singh and Hasnain , ], all have water chemistries that plot on both sides of the open system line. The chemistry of Fjallsjökull, Iceland [ Raiswell and Thomas , ], diverges substantially from the open system line, implying closed system depletion of CO 2 . But its high alkalinity suggests substantial open system behavior occurred before closure.…”