Socioeconomic Status and the Experience of Pain: An Example from Knees

Abstract

Reports of pain differ markedly across socioeconomic groups and are correlated with outcomes such as functional limitations and disability insurance receipt. This paper examines the differential experience of pain by education. We focus on knee pain, the most common musculoskeletal complaint. Comparing clinical interpretation of knee x-rays of people with and without pain, there are few differences in presence or clinical severity of arthritis across education groups. In contrast, less educated people report more pain for any given objective measure of arthritis. After confirming that reported pain maps to objective measures like walking speed and range of motion, we test four theories for differential experience of pain: differences in obesity, physically demanding occupations, psychological factors, and medical treatment differences. We find that physical demands on the job and obesity each explain about one-third of the education gradient in knee pain. There is an interaction between the two; physical requirements on the job are associated with knee pain primarily in those who are obese. In contrast, psychological traits and access to medical care explain little of the difference in reported pain by education level. These findings imply that educational gradients in pain are likely to persist or even widen as the need for physically demanding occupations-like home health aides and personal service workers-grows in importance with the aging population, and the working population continues to be obese.

Rising Geographic Disparities in US Mortality

“…Individuals invest in health capital though behaviors such as regular exercise and maintaining a proper diet. Health capital depreciates over time at a rate that increases with age and in response to factors such as poor health behaviors, stress, and physically demanding occupations (Cutler, Meara, and Stewart 2020). The health-capital framework suggests that various factors have long-lasting effects that "come home to roost" in midlife mortality data many decades on.…”

Living and Dying in America: An Essay on Deaths of Despair and the Future of Capitalism

“…Chapter 9 provides a brilliant discussion of opioids, starting with the Opium war between China and Britain in the early 19 th century and extending through their current key contribution to recent increases in DSL mortality. Case and Deaton describe the different 5 A recent analysis by Cutler et al (2020) finds that knee pain (the most common musculoskeletal complaint) declines with education, with greater pain levels among the less educated largely explained by higher rates of obesity, more physically demanding jobs, and interactions between the two. 6 This is not quite correct.…”

A health economic theory of occupational choice, aging, and longevity

“…See Strulik (2021) for an introduction of pain and pain treatment into health economic theory. See Cutler et al (2020) on the differential experience of pain by socioeconomic status.…”