Social Networking as a Development Tool: A Critical Reflection

Abstract

The convergence of community development and participatory democracy philosophies and practices supports social networking as a key tool to address urban social issues. The proliferation of formalised social networks is examined here to provide a New Zealand example of global trends towards fostering 'social capital' to address urban social problems. Social networking is situated in a participatory governance context and critiques of neo-liberalism and Bourdieu's formulation of social capital are used to consider divergent and often conflicting expectations and practices of networking. Ethnographic data are used to demonstrate that, for some ethnic minority groupings, perverse economic incentives meant that it was more advantageous to maintain a marginalised position rather than to participate in 'community' networks. Evidence of increasing levels of multiscale collaboration is qualified by such exclusions of some sectors of community and the continuation of strategic agendas developed without community input.

Capturing the benefits that emerge from regional sustainability networks: The Castile–La Mancha network of sustainable cities and towns

“…Coenen () states that municipalities find it difficult to encounter equal and relevant partners for dialogue (NGOs and other actors, for instance, need to be well organized to play a role in LA21). Similarly, while some groups may be over‐represented it is difficult to involve other groups, such as the business community or ordinary people (Scott and Liew ). And it seems to be easier to involve people around immediate issues (such as nuisance, litter and graffiti) than long‐term issues (Coenen ).…”

Social innovation for urban liveability. Empirical evidence from the Italian third sector

“…Secondly, a notable relationship-wise dimension (i.e. volunteer involvement) has been identified in many of the initiatives, in terms of ability to involve people and to attract volunteers and to generate social networks of trust and support, which in turn leads to empowered communities, or healthy, connected and civically active communities (Scott and Liew, 2012). Portofranco is one example of this aspect.…”

The networking practices of women managers in an emerging economy setting: negotiating institutional and social barriers

“…Our first contribution is to networking theory (Scott and Liew, ) in that we highlight how women sometimes use networking ineffectively. The women in our sample formed strong ties with a limited number of people, but these ties often lacked influence (Browne, ).…”