Social Network, Surgeon, and Media Influence on the Decision to Undergo Contralateral Prophylactic Mastectomy

Abstract

Objectives:The rate of contralateral prophylactic mastectomy (CPM) has risen sharply in the past decade. The current study was designed to examine social network, surgeon, and media influence on patients’ CPM decision-making, examining not only who influenced the decision, and to what extent, but also the type of influence exerted.Methods:Patients (N=113) who underwent CPM at 4 Indiana University–affiliated hospitals between 2008 and 2012 completed structured telephone interviews in 2013. Questions addressed the involvement and influence of the social network (family, friends, and nonsurgeon health professionals), surgeon, and media on the CPM decision.Results:Spouses, children, family, friends, and health professionals were reported as exerting a meaningful degree of influence on patients’ decisions, largely in ways that were positive or neutral toward CPM. Most surgeons were regarded as providing options rather than encouraging or discouraging CPM. Media influence was present, but limited.Conclusions:Patients who choose CPM do so with influence and support from members of their social networks. Reversing the increasing choice of CPM will require educating these influential others, which can be accomplished by encouraging patients to include them in clinical consultations, and by providing patients with educational materials that can be shared with their social networks. Surgeons need to be perceived as having an opinion, specifically that CPM should be reserved for those patients for whom it is medically indicated.

Bilateral Mastectomy in Women With Unilateral Breast Cancer

“…There is increasing information and opinions in mainstream media and social networks about women who experience breast cancer, including several celebrities . Women can post online about their personal experiences with breast cancer.…”

A Response and Discussion with Respect to Gulcelik’s Study in Oncoplastic Level II Surgical Techniques for Breast Cancer Treatment

“…Nowadays, there is a growth of the number of conservative breast treatments as science divulgation is uprising and surgeons can learn from these techniques. However, due to social media effects, there has also been a great increase in the concern of the female population about breast cancer, which had led to more prophylactic mastectomies [12]. It is important not to forget that every patient could experience this process in a unique way, and some patients may react differently than medical doctors think they would.…”

Genetic Counseling, Screening and Risk-Reducing Surgery in Patients with Primary Breast Cancer and Germline BRCA Mutations: Unmet Needs in Low- and Middle-Income Countries

“…These recommendations are based on studies in countries with robust health systems 41 . Genetic counseling should be an important companion of those statements for LMICs, and also in High-Income Countries (HICs) where the need of genetic counseling is further increased because of the explosion of genetic and genomic changes with related prognostic and therapeutic values 42,43 .…”