Social network analysis and whole genome sequencing in a cohort study to investigate TB transmission in an educational setting

Abstract

Background TB outbreaks in educational institutions can result in significant transmission and pose a considerable threat to TB control. Investigation using traditional microbiological and epidemiological tools can lead to imprecise screening strategies due to difficulties characterising complex transmission networks. Application of whole genome sequencing (WGS) and social network analysis can provide additional information that may facilitate rapid directed public health action. We report the utility of these methods in combination with traditional approaches for the first time to investigate a TB outbreak in an educational setting. Methods Latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) cases were screenees with a positive T-SPOT®. TB test. Active TB cases were defined through laboratory confirmation of M. tuberculosis on culture or through clinical or radiological findings consistent with infection. Epidemiological data were collected from institutional records and screenees. Samples were cultured and analysed using traditional M. tuberculosis typing and WGS. We undertook multivariable multinomial regression and social network analysis to identify exposures associated with case status and risk communities. Results We identified 189 LTBI cases (13.7% positivity rate) and nine active TB cases from 1377 persons screened. The LTBI positivity rate was 39.1% (99/253) among persons who shared a course with an infectious case (odds ratio 7.3, 95% confidence interval [CI] 5.2 to 10.3). The community structure analysis divided the students into five communities based on connectivity, as opposed to the 11 shared courses. Social network analysis identified that the community including the suspected index case was at significantly elevated risk of active disease (odds ratio 7.5, 95% CI 1.3 to 44.0) and contained eight persons who were lost to follow-up. Five sputum samples underwent WGS, four had zero single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) differences and one had a single SNP difference. Conclusion This study demonstrates the public health impact an undiagnosed case of active TB disease can have in an educational setting within a low incidence area. Social network analysis and whole genome sequencing provided greater insight to evolution of the transmission network and identification of communities of risk. These tools provide further information over traditional epidemiological and microbiological approaches to direct public health action in this setting.

Use of a Whole Genome Sequencing-based approach for Mycobacterium tuberculosis surveillance in Europe in 2017–2019: an ECDC pilot study

“…First, although WGS has the potential to provide data for close to “real-time surveillance”, the intrinsic delays due to culture, batching and referral of the MTBC isolates to the sequencing laboratories affected our capacity to identify clusters promptly and to perform a prospective type of analysis. Although beyond the scope of the study, this limited the impact of our results on public health, as successfully shown in other local settings [ 29 , 30 ]. The availability of more affordable and portable sequencing platforms could contribute to reducing this delay by increasing accessibility to this technology.…”

A model of tuberculosis clustering in low incidence countries reveals more transmission in the United Kingdom than the Netherlands between 2010 and 2015

“…Over the past 20 years, genotyping has informed our knowledge of how TB evolved, spread around the world, and survives within hosts [6][7][8]. Unlike genotyping for other pathogens, TB genotyping cannot always definitively identify who-infected-whom, as epidemiologicallylinked cases are often infected with genetically indistinguishable strains [9,10]. Furthermore, cases infected by indistinguishable strains may be epidemiologically unrelated, due to infection with a common strain [11].…”

Logically Inferred Tuberculosis Transmission (LITT): A Data Integration Algorithm to Rank Potential Source Cases

“…In addition, it cannot be used to infer direction of transmission without additional data. Fully understanding TB transmission requires not just an analysis of Mtb sequences, but also integration of the clinical and epidemiological characteristics of the patients ( 21 , 22 ).…”