Social Innovation For Health Research: Development of the SIFHR Checklist

Abstract

Background Social innovations in health are inclusive solutions to address the healthcare delivery gap that meet the needs of end users through a multi-stakeholder, community-engaged process. While social innovations in health have shown promise in closing the healthcare delivery gap, more research is needed to evaluate, scale up, and sustain social innovation. Research checklists can standardize and improve reporting of research findings, promote transparency, and increase replicability of study results and findings. Methods and findings The research checklist was developed through a 3-step community-engaged process, including a global open call for ideas, a scoping review, and a 3-round modified Delphi process. The call for entries solicited checklists and related items and was open between November 27, 2019 and February 1, 2020. In addition to the open call submissions and scoping review findings, a 17-item Social Innovation For Health Research (SIFHR) Checklist was developed based on the Template for Intervention Description and Replication (TIDieR) Checklist. The checklist was then refined during 3 rounds of Delphi surveys conducted between May and June 2020. The resulting checklist will facilitate more complete and transparent reporting, increase end-user engagement, and help assess social innovation projects. A limitation of the open call was requiring internet access, which likely discouraged participation of some subgroups. Conclusions The SIFHR Checklist will strengthen the reporting of social innovation in health research studies. More research is needed on social innovation for health.

Identification of social innovation in health criteria in Latin America

“…This search revealed various efforts from different hubs in the world, including that in Latin America. Kpokiri et al 18 provided a checklist that defined 17 items important for describing SIHI, of which 13 items are compatible with those identified in this review, while 4 are not directly related.…”

Reporta Health: a mobile social innovation for crowdsourcing data on illegal health facilities in Nigeria

“…This stack has been previously applied for the same purpose 14. We also used the social innovation checklist consisting of 17-line items to ensure that this social innovation (Reporta Health) met the needs of a social innovation 15…”

Social innovation in health, community engagement, financing and outcomes: qualitative analysis from the social innovation in health initiative

“…In addition, research has not explored relationships between Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and health and non-health outputs emerging from social innovations. Better understanding community engagement, financing and outcomes related to social innovation will help to expand this field and increase the rigour of research 6. TDR (the UNDP/UNICEF/World Bank/WHO Special Programme for research and training in tropical diseases), the WHO and other organisations have underlined the importance of high-quality research on social innovation 5 7…”