Social Ecology of Asthma

Abstract

This article describes a process for integrating health behavior and social science theories with practice-based insights using participatory systems thinking and diagramming methods largely inspired by system dynamics methods. This integration can help close the gap between research and practice in health education and health behavior by offering a systematic approach to bring together stakeholders across multiple domains. In this process we create a diagram using constructs from multiple health behavior theories at all levels of the social ecological framework as variables in causal loop diagrams. The goal of this process is to elucidate the reciprocal relationships between explanatory factors at various levels of the social ecological framework that render so many public health problems intractable. To illustrate, we detail a theory-based, replicable process for creating a qualitative diagram to enrich understanding of caregiver and provider behavior around adherence to pediatric asthma action plans. We describe how such diagramming can serve as the foundation for translating evidence into practice to address real-world challenges. Key insights gained include recognition of the complex, multilevel factors affecting whether, and how effectively, parents/caregivers and medical providers co-create an asthma action plan, and important "feedback" dynamics at play that can support or derail ongoing collaboration. Although this article applies this method to asthma action plan adherence in children, the method and resulting diagrams are applicable and adaptable to other health behaviors requiring continuous, daily action.

Building community resilience to prevent and mitigate community impact of gun violence: conceptual framework and intervention design

“…44 System dynamics modelling is a method that describes dynamic, multilevel, linear and non-linear processes required so that solutions to challenging social problems like gun violence can be identified. [45][46][47][48][49][50][51] We will assemble a multisector group to engage in a series of these group model building sessions to create a causal loop diagram. A causal loop diagram is a visualisation of how different variables in a system are inter-related.…”

A framework for measuring self-management effectiveness and health care use among pediatric asthma patients and families

“…The above discussion highlights the importance of considering the socioecological model of asthma prevention and management, which has been embraced by public health agencies (such as the CDC), as a framework for guiding interventions for chronic disease prevention and management 63,64. According to the socioecological model, people exist within a system of relationships, within complex layers of environments that impact on their lives.…”

Simulating system dynamics of the HIV care continuum to achieve treatment as prevention

“…Participatory system dynamics (SD) modeling brings stakeholders together to examine complex problems at the community level [18,19]. The approach has been used to examine various public health concerns [20][21][22][23][24], including HIV/AIDS [25][26][27]. Participatory SD modeling engages stakeholders in an iterative "systems thinking" process that contributes to model building by diagraming, critiquing, seeking data to quantify and calibrate, and simulating interactive systems-level dynamics with the aid of computer tools [28][29][30].…”