Social Determinants of Health in Managed Care Payment Formulas

Abstract

IMPORTANCE Managed care payment formulas commonly allocate more money for medically complex populations, but ignore most social determinants of health (SDH).OBJECTIVE To add SDH variables to a diagnosis-based payment formula that allocates funds to managed care plans and accountable care organizations. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTSUsing data from MassHealth, the Massachusetts Medicaid and Children's Health Insurance Program, we estimated regression models predicting Medicaid spending using a diagnosis-based and SDH-expanded model, and compared the accuracy of their cost predictions overall and for vulnerable populations. MassHealth members enrolled for at least 6 months in 2013 in fee-for-service (FFS) programs (n = 357 660) or managed care organizations (MCOs) (n = 524 607).EXPOSURES We built cost prediction models from a fee-for-service program. Predictors in the diagnosis-based model are age, sex, and diagnoses from claims. The SDH model adds predictors describing housing instability, behavioral health issues, disability, and neighborhood-level stressors.MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Overall model explanatory power and overpayments and underpayments for subgroups of interest for all Medicaid-reimbursable expenditures excepting long-term support services (mean annual cost = $5590 per member). RESULTSWe studied 357 660 people who were FFS participants and 524 607 enrolled in MCOs with a combined 806 889 person-years of experience. The FFS program experience included more men (49.6% vs 43.6%), older patients (mean age of 26.1 years vs 21.6 years), and sicker patients (mean morbidity score of 1.16 vs 0.89) than MCOs. Overall, the SDH model performed well, but only slightly better than the diagnosis-based model, explaining most of the spending variation in the managed care population (validated R 2 = 62.4) and reducing underpayments for several vulnerable populations. For example, raw costs for the quintile of people living in the most stressed neighborhoods were 9.6% ($537 per member per year) higher than average. Since greater medical morbidity accounts for much of this difference, the diagnosis-based model underpredicts costs for the most stressed quintile by about 2.1% ($130 per member per year). The expanded model eliminates the neighborhood-based underpayment, as well as underpayments of 72% for clients of the Department of Mental Health (observed costs of about $30 000 per year) and of 7% for those with serious mental illness (observed costs of about $16 000 per year).CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE Since October 2016, MassHealth has used an expanded model to allocate payments from a prespecified total budget to managed care organizations according to their enrollees' social and medical risk. Extra payments for socially vulnerable individuals could fund activities, such as housing assistance, that could improve health equity.

Long‐Term Nursing Home Entry: A Prognostic Model for Older Adults with a Family or Unpaid Caregiver

“…Results from this study are timely in light of recent deliberations regarding whether and how to account for social factors in Medicare payment policy 40,41 and awareness of the potential value to be derived from more systematic recognition and effective support of family in care delivery. 42,43 The enduring commitment and intensity of family help is widely recognized; in this study, family caregivers were providing nearly 34 hours of care per week on average.…”

The Value of Unstructured Electronic Health Record Data in Geriatric Syndrome Case Identification

“…[32][33][34][35] The implications of using EHR free-text to extract noncoded or nonclinical variables are critical for the overall agenda of population health and managed care, which heavily focuses on high-risk geriatric populations and integration of social determinants of health into payment adjustments. 36,37 Furthermore, because geriatric syndromes are usually not classic disease states, they have not received attention commensurate with their effect on health and well-being in common diagnostic coding systems such as ICD and SNOMED. 20 Administrating comprehensive geriatric assessment is resource intensive and might be impractical for all older adults in all settings.…”

Massachusetts Community-Based Organization Perspectives on Medicaid Redesign

“…15,17,35 Similarly, much has been written about a new risk-adjustment methodology wherein Massachusetts Medicaid ACOs that have unhoused patients assigned to them will receive additional funding. 36 It was unclear until recently whether the additional funding was intended to cover medical costs or to fund housing solutions, leaving housing CBOs to believe that there may be funds earmarked for their services. Lack of communication from Medicaid ACOs about what would be provided in exchange for CBO participation in a contract added further uncertainty.…”