Social, Clinical and Microbiological Differential Characteristics of Tuberculosis among Immigrants in Spain

Abstract

BackgroundTo identify the differential tuberculosis (TB) characteristics within the immigrant population with respect to natives in Spain.Methodology/Principal FindingsA prospective cohort study design was implemented to examine the TB cases diagnosed and starting standard antituberculous treatment in Spain, between January 1st 2006 and March 31st 2007. A logistic regression analysis was performed to determine differential characteristics. 1,490 patients were included in the study population, 1,048 natives and 442 (29.7%) immigrants. According to the multivariate analysis, the following variables were significantly associated with immigrant TB cases: younger age (OR = 3.79; CI:2.16–6.62), living in group situation (OR = 7.61; CI:3.38–12.12), lower frequency of disabled (OR:0.08; CI:0.02–0.26) and retired (OR:0.21; CI:0.09–0.48) employment status, lower frequency of pulmonary disease presentation (OR = 0.47; CI:0.24–0.92), primary or emergency care admission (OR = 1.80; CI:1.05–3.06 and OR = 2.16; CI:1.36–3.45), drug resistance (OR = 1.86; CI:1.01–3.46), treatment default (OR:2.12; CI:1.18–3.81), lower frequency of alcohol and cigarette consumption (OR = 2.10; CI:1.42–3.11 and OR = 2.85; CI:2.10–3.87 respectively), more directly observed treatment (OR = 1.68; CI:1.04–2.69), and poor understanding of TB disease and its treatment (OR = 3.11; CI:1.86–5.20). The low percentage of primary MDR-TB in the native population (0.1% vs. 2.2% of immigrants) should be noted.Conclusions/SignificanceThe differences show the need to introduce specific strategies in the management of TB within the immigrant population, including the improvement of social and work conditions.

Spanish Compliance With Guidelines for Prescribing Four Drugs in the Intensive Phase of Standard Tuberculosis Treatment

“…8 Moreover, the percentage of foreign patients among the overall population of TB patients in Spain is 29.7%, according to a previous study, 12 and 35% according to our study, underlining the inadvisability and high risk of initiating 3drug treatment. This practice is clinically inacceptable, since the resistance rates in immigrant patients are known to be higher than in Spanish nationals (11.9% isoniazid resistance in immigrants, compared to 4.1% in nationals, according to a recent Spanish study).…”

Social and Clinical Characteristics of Immigrants with Tuberculosis in South Korea

“…The default rate in immigrants with TB in other study has been reported to be 11.5%13 and 19.5%14 depending on situations. To decrease default rate, political countermeasures such as strengthening emigration and immigration control and intensifying PPM collaboration by tracing TB medications of immigrants or directly observed treatment might be needed.…”

Tuberculosis Transmission among Immigrants and Autochthonous Populations of the Eastern Province of Saudi Arabia

“…Poor nutrition, lack of fresh air, stress and hardships may also favor reactivation of remote infection followed by transmission under such conditions. Added to that drug resistance might promote subsequent clinical manifestations also [39,40]. Unfortunately contact tracing data were not available to further assess the hypothesis of local transmission within this specific study group, or within e.g.…”