Social Acceptance of a Multi-Purpose Reservoir in a Recently Deglaciated Landscape in the Swiss Alps

Abstract

Climate change impacts such as shrinking glaciers and decreasing snow cover are expected to cause changes in the water balance throughout the 21st century. New proglacial lakes in recently deglaciated areas could be used for mitigation measures such as hydropower production and adaptation measures to temporarily retain water and transfer it seasonally to compensate for seasonal water scarcity. Such multi-purpose reservoirs could counterbalance the water currently provided by glaciers and the seasonal snowpack. However, new dam projects often face various conflicts due to their impact on nature, biodiversity, and the landscape. This article presents the determinants for social acceptance of the first reservoir in a recently deglaciated landscape in the Swiss Alps. Three main determinants were identified: (1) the forthcoming popular vote on the national Swiss Energy Strategy 2050; (2) the participatory process, which contains a polycentric design; and (3) the project area, which does not yet have protected status. The three determinants facilitate social acceptance of the dam project, but lead to less attention on using the stored water for multiple services. These findings have implications on sustainable development, because dams in recently deglaciated areas support the transition to renewable energy sources, but transform a natural resource system into a hydroelectric landscape.

River Connectivity is Crucial for Safeguarding Biodiversity but May be Socially Overlooked. Insights From Spanish University Students

“…However, there was a small difference in the gap between the two most and the two least valued rivers, which was smaller for natural sciences students than for students of the other disciplines. This difference at such small scale is interesting and supports the idea that participatory processes involving multiple sectors are determinant in the public acceptance of interventions in rivers (Kellner, 2019). Our result illustrates the importance of involving different populations sectors when making environmental decisions about river uses.…”

“…To incorporate connectivity restoration in conservation programs, it is crucial to improve societal awareness about the importance of maintaining continuous rivers (Couvet et al, 2008). However, so far studies have been focused on the public acceptance of new dams and other river infrastructures in relation with energy and water supply (Cohen et al, 2014;Boyé and De Vivo, 2016;Kellner, 2019;Schulz et al, 2019), rather than on the consideration of connectivity. Reservoirs provide hydroelectric power, reducing the dependence from fossil oils, and provide water supply and recreation that are important services for the population and increase their public acceptance (Arabatzis and Myronidis, 2011).…”

Reservoir Governance in World's Water Towers Needs to Anticipate Multi‐purpose Use

“…The results of the water resources analysis show that the water available in the Trift reser-KELLNER AND BRUNNER 10.1029/2020EF001643 voir would be sufficient to cover a substantial part of current and future downstream water shortages, partly, even under extreme conditions. Still, the actors involved in the participatory process leading to the draft concession did not consider downstream water needs in their decision-making even though the concession constitutes a property right und could not be adapted before its expiration in 80 years (Kellner, 2019).…”

Volume, formation and sedimentation of future glacier lakes in Switzerland

“…Recent debates around this topic -mostly happening in the context of artificial reservoirs rather than natural lakes (e.g. Kellner, 2019;Kellner and Brunner, 2021;Kellner, 2021) have focused on the potentials for multipurpose usage, i.e. the potential of a given lake to satisfy different needs.…”