Smartphone-Based Interventions and Internalizing Disorders in Youth: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Abstract

Background Mental health disorders in youth are a global issue that have important implications for the future quality of life and morbidity of affected individuals. In the context of public health initiatives, smartphone-based interventions have been suggested to hold the potential to be an effective strategy to reduce the symptoms of mental health disorders in youth; however, further evaluation is needed to confirm their effectiveness. This systematic review and meta-analysis documents and synthesizes existing research on smartphone-based interventions targeting internalizing disorders in youth populations. Objective This study aims to synthesize existing research on smartphone-based interventions targeting internalizing disorders in youth populations. Methods PubMed and SCOPUS were searched in 2019, and 4334 potentially relevant articles were found. A total of 12 studies were included in the final synthesis. We used the Hedges g meta-analysis approach and a random effects model for analysis. Results The results of this review note that depression and anxiety are the most commonly targeted symptoms, and unlike other similar topics, most studies reviewed were linked to a proven treatment. The overall pooled effect from the meta-analysis showed small but significant effects (κ=12; N=1370; Hedges g=0.20; 95% CI 0.02-0.38) for interventions in reducing the symptoms of internalizing disorders. In total, 4 subgroup analyses examining specific symptoms and intervention styles found varied small significant and nonsignificant effects. Conclusions Future research should focus on developing robust evaluative frameworks and examining interventions among more diverse populations and settings. More robust research is needed before smartphone-based interventions are scaled up and used at the population level to address youth internalizing disorders.

Systematic Analysis of Effectiveness of Using Mobile Technologies (MT) in Teaching and Learning Foreign Language

“…The study indicated high-risk addictions, resulting in low self-regulated smartphones. Similarly, Buttazzoni et al (2021) concur with this research that smartphones spend most users' time and don't.…”

“…The smartphone usage of students is both negatively and beneficial depends on how it is utilised, according to Buttazzoni et al (2021). The author further stresses that the smartphone has become a big distraction from studying on the wrong sides of the coin.…”

“…The research papers on this topic have indicated increased improvements in the performance of foreign language learners and combined application studies(Sletten, 2021).The paradigm of technology-supported classrooms has changed mobile devices and related technologies. The use of such technologies can contribute to the accomplishment and retention of learners, support all levels of learning difficulties, and reach students who otherwise would not be able to take part in education(Buttazzoni et al, 2021).…”

Are online mental health interventions for youth effective? A systematic review

“…Previous reviews investigating the effectiveness of app-based mental health interventions found a similar trend. 70 This potentially reflects the fact that app-based interventions are still in the nascent stages. More rigorous designs of apps for youth mental health are needed.…”

A cognitive behavioural therapy smartphone app for adolescent depression and anxiety: co-design of ClearlyMe

“…A recent systematic review found only 12 studies that evaluated smartphone-based interventions for internalising disorders in adolescents. Only three of these interventions were based on CBT and none were apps for depression or anxiety disorders or symptoms (Buttazzoni et al, 2021). Smartphones provide unceasing access to software, internet and multimedia functionality.…”