Edited by Charles E. SamuelThe nucleotide incorporation fidelity of the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) is important for maintaining functional genetic information but, at the same time, is also important for generating sufficient genetic diversity to escape the bottlenecks of the host's antiviral response. We have previously shown that the structural dynamics of the motif D loop are closely related to nucleotide discrimination. Previous studies have also suggested that there is a reorientation of the triphosphate of the incoming nucleotide, which is essential before nucleophilic attack from the primer RNA 3-hydroxyl. Here, we have used 31 P NMR with poliovirus RdRp to show that the binding environment of the triphosphate is different when correct versus incorrect nucleotide binds. We also show that amino acid substitutions at residues known to interact with the triphosphate can alter the binding orientation/environment of the nucleotide, sometimes lead to protein conformational changes, and lead to substantial changes in RdRp fidelity. The analyses of other fidelity variants also show that changes in the triphosphate binding environment are not always accompanied by changes in the structural dynamics of the motif D loop or other regions known to be important for RdRp fidelity, including motif B. Altogether, our studies suggest that the conformational changes in motifs B and D, and the nucleoside triphosphate reorientation represent separable, "tunable" fidelity checkpoints.Genome maintenance and propagation are dependent on faithful and efficient nucleic acid replication catalyzed by a large superfamily of template-directed polymerases (1). In each cycle of nucleotide addition, these polymerases must efficiently select the correct nucleotide that will properly base-pair with the template strand against a large pool of non-cognate nucleotides. The fidelity of nucleotide selection is essential for the integrity and proper expression of the genome. However, evolutionary processes require some level of incorrect nucleotide incorporation to generate the genetic diversity that allows a population of organisms to survive challenges from their environment. RNA viruses especially exemplify these ideas. For these viruses, it is now well established that the accuracy of RNA replication is a key determinant of viral virulence (2-6). Many RNA-dependent RNA polymerases (RdRps) 3 that are responsible for RNA viral genome replication operate near a limit of fine tuned mutation frequency, which optimally balances genetic diversity with overall genome integrity (7). Antiviral compounds like ribavirin that push the RdRp past an "error threshold" lead to the generation of too many replication errors and the loss of functional genetic information (7). However, variant RdRps with more stringent nucleotide selection criteria may not generate the genetic diversity that allows a virus population to escape the bottlenecks of the host's antiviral response. Indeed, it has been shown that viruses encoding variant RdRps with eit...