“…Furthermore, some recent studies from China have discussed the effect of economic development on carbon emissions and the environment (Umar et al 2020;Li, Lui, Gibson and Zhu, 2012;Cheng and Li, 2019;Lei and Shimokawa, 2020). A wide range of research has looked at the implementation of sustainability targets in the BRICS countries separately: Brazil (Da Silva, Selig, and Bellen, 2014), Russia (Su, Wang, Streimikiene, Balezentis and Zhang, 2019;Kılkış, 2016), India (Bisht and Thakur, 2019;Patel, Sharma and Singh, 2020;Spillias, and Shimokawa, 2020;Umar, Ji, Kirikkaleli and Xu, 2020), and South Africa (Moldan, Janoušková, and Hák, 2012;Geijzendorffer et al 2017;Dos Santos, Svensson and Padin, 2013). On the basis of the above arguments from both the theoretical and the empirical literature, the following hypothesis is posited:…”