Small NGOs and Agenda-Setting in Global Conservation Governance: The Case of Pangolin Conservation

Abstract

The study of global environmental governance suggests that agenda-setting power is concentrated in a handful of high-profile, leading nongovernmental organizations (NGOs). The recent rise of interest in pangolin conservation constitutes a deviant case in this theoretical tradition. In order to explain the puzzle, I introduce a new theory of small NGO influence and illustrate the mechanisms through the case study of pangolin conservation. Based on in-depth interviews with conservation NGOs, I show how small NGOs raised the salience of pangolin trafficking in global conservation governance by appealing to the shared values of the people who are highly interested in conservation. Moreover, the targeting of traditional Chinese medicine as the driver of pangolin extinction, while unintentionally, helped raise the salience of pangolin trafficking by leveraging the rise of anti-Chinese sentiment in the Global North. Finally, small NGOs were able to use their expertise to guide leading NGOs and state officials in rule-making processes. The findings offer a corrective to the hierarchical view of civil society, calling for more careful evaluations of small NGOs in global conservation governance.

Does Science Shape Sentiment? Scientific Inputs and the Deliberations in the Convention on Biological Diversity

“…Haas and Haas (1995, 277) explain how “Organizations that learned were ruled by a dominant coalition whose members were in agreement on the main principles of world order” (see also: Ingebritsen, 2002; Tobin, 2017; and Kopra, 2020). Aside from such state-based coalitions, the literature has emphasized the influence of nongovernmental organizations acting as norm entrepreneurs in these processes (Park, 2005; Ayling & Gunningham, 2017; Blondeel et al, 2019; Shibaike, 2022). Influence from scientific assessments is thus carried by a key set of actors in the political negotiations.…”

The influence of Antarctic governance on marine protected areas in the Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction Agreement negotiations

“…Emails were obtained for all participants (N = 20), and a total of three emails requesting interviews were sent out to each person. 10 persons responded to the interview request (50% success rate), three who were affiliated with government agencies, and seven who were affiliated with non-governmental organizations (NGOs) 100 . Highly visible NGOs may influence the governance process through acting as a boundary organization, providing scientific and sociopolitical guidance to state actors 101 .…”

Rescue and rehabilitation capacity needed to save live pangolins seized from illegal wildlife trade in Nepal

“…Globally, pangolins are under serious threat of extinction, mainly due to poaching, illegal trade and habitat destruction. Meanwhile, there are growing efforts and interest in saving pangolins, including from governments, academia and conservation NGOs (Heighton & Gaubert, 2021;Shibaike, 2021). The eight surviving species of pangolins comprise the most traded mammal species globally, causing their wild populations to decline at an alarming rate (Challender, Nash, & Waterman, 2020).…”