“…Most impurities that are dissolved in water become excluded during ice crystallization, with the exception of a few acids (HF and HCl), ammonia (NH 3 ), alkalis (KOH and NaOH), and their derivatives (NH 4 F or KCl) that drastically change the protonic carrier concentration [e.g., Petrenko and Whitworth , ]. KOH inclusion into THF hydrate has also been demonstrated to trigger formation of charge carriers, Bjerrum and protonic defects, and could also affect mobilities of other point defects [ Nelson et al , ]. If CH 4 hydrate behaves similar to ice, then the sand may have contributed KOH and its derivative KCl during synthesis, which is consistent with IC detection of both K + water melted from samples containing sand (runs 5 and 6), but not in those containing glass beads (run 7) or in those that did contain any sediment (run 3) (Table S1).…”