Skin-to-deltoid-muscle distance at three recommended sites for intramuscular vaccination in a population with obesity: an observational study

Abstract

aim: Worldwide, immunisation guidelines variably locate the deltoid injection site based on anatomical landmarks. This may influence the skin-to-deltoid-muscle distance and therefore the needle length required to achieve intramuscular injection. Obesity is associated with increased skin-to-deltoid-muscle distance, but it is unknown whether the injection site location chosen in individuals with obesity impacts the needle length required for intramuscular injection. The aim of the study was to estimate the differences in skin-to-deltoidmuscle distance between three different vaccine injection sites recommended by the national guidelines of the United States of America (USA), Australia and New Zealand, in obese adults. The study also explored i) the associations between skin-to-deltoid-muscle distance across the three recommended sites with sex, body mass index (BMI), and arm circumference, and ii) the proportion of participants with a skin-to-deltoid-muscle distance >20 millimetres (mm), in whom the standard 25mm needle length would not ensure deposition of vaccine within the deltoid muscle. method: Non-interventional cross-sectional study in a single site, non-clinical setting in Wellington, New Zealand. Forty participants (29 females), aged ≥18 years, with obesity (BMI>30 kilograms [km]/m 2 ). Measurements included distance from acromion to injection sites, BMI, arm circumference, and skin-to-deltoid-muscle distance measured by ultrasound at each recommended injection site. results: Mean (SD) skin-to-deltoid-muscle distances for USA, Australia and New Zealand sites were 13.96mm (4.54), 17.94mm (6.08) and 20.26mm (5.91) respectively, with a mean (95% confidence interval) for the distance between Australia minus New Zealand -2.7mm (-3.5 to -1.9), P<0.001; and USA minus New Zealand -7.6 mm (-8.5 to -6.7); P<0.001. Skin-to-deltoid-muscle distance was greater in females and was positively associated with BMI and arm circumference. The proportions with a skin-to-deltoid-muscle distance >20 mm were 45%, 40% and 15% for the New Zealand, Australia and USA sites respectively. However, the sample size was relatively small, limiting interpretation in specific sub-groups. conclusion: There were marked differences in the skin-to-deltoid-muscle distance between the three recommended injection sites studied. When choosing the required needle length to achieve intramuscular vaccination in obese vaccine recipients, consideration needs to be given to the injection site location, sex, BMI and/or arm circumference, as these factors all influence the skin-to-deltoidmuscle distance. A standard needle length of 25mm may be insufficient to ensure deposition of vaccine into the deltoid muscle in a substantive proportion of adults with obesity. Research is urgently required to determine anthropometric measurement cut-points that can be used to enable appropriate needle length selection to ensure intramuscular vaccination.