Skill differentiation between formal and informal employment

Abstract

PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to examine the existence of skill differentiation between formal and informal labor markets.Design/methodology/approachFirst, a theoretical model is developed under the assumption that concealment of production is increasingly costly for informal firms. Second, using data on the Brazilian self‐employed economy, two methods are utilized to compare earnings in the formal versus the informal economy: propensity score and instrumental variable (IV) methods. For the IV estimations, state‐level variables are used as instruments for individual's decisions. In addition, the effect of schooling on formality choice is analyzed.FindingsThe theoretical model implies that more productive firms tend to operate formally and the proportion of workers employed by formal firms is larger for higher skilled workers. In the empirical analysis, it is found that formal firms are more productive than informal firms, controlling for workers' characteristics, and that higher workers' skill increase the probability of formal operation, as predicted by the theoretical model.Originality/valueThe paper provides an original theoretical model of skill differentiation in labor markets and empirically evaluates the implications of the model.

Estimating the effects of the minimum wage in a developing country: A density discontinuity design approach

“…Another feature of the minimum wage changes in Brazil is that, since 1 Firms face a trade-off between the costs of complying with the regulation and the probability/magnitude of punishment. The firms' decision to hire formal versus informal workers was investigated in Almeida and Carneiro (2012), Mattos and Ogura (2009), and Galiani and Weinschelbaum (2012), among many others. 2 The constitution allows for states to set occupation-specific wage floors, as long as they are above the federal level.…”

Estimating the Effects of the Minimum Wage in a Developing Country: A Density Discontinuity Design Approach

“…I maintain all assumptions from Doyle -or Meyer and Wise, if one prefers a parametric specification for latent wages -and generalize their approach to address sector-specific responses. Assumption 4, the assump- 12 The conditions needed for identification under unobserved heterogeneity are discussed in Appendix D.…”

Good jobs and bad jobs for Indonesia's informal workers

“…Heckman correction procedures have been used by a number of studies, such as Heckman and Hotz (1986) for Panama, and Marcouiller, Ruiz de Castilla and Woodruff (1997) for three Latin American countries. More recently, Mattos and Ogura (2009) used the proportion of beneficiaries of public pension funds per state as the instrument for selection into formal employment in Brazil. A common finding in these types of studies is that the earnings gap decreases substantially once selection is accounted for.…”