Singing in primary schools: case studies of good practice in whole class vocal tuition

Abstract

Within the context of British initiatives in music education such as the Wider Opportunities programme in England and the recommendations of the Music Manifesto emphasising the importance of singing in primary schools, the current paper explores examples of good practice in whole-class vocal tuition. The research included seven different primary schools in England and combined observational methods and semi-structured interviews with musicians, teachers and headteachers. Results indicate a variety of successful approaches to promoting singing in primary schools. Essential motivators for developing singing include an enthusiastic staff member, a supportive headteacher and support from other school staff. Additional motivators include access to musical expertise within and beyond the school, and a singing leader with keyboard skills. Challenges to good practice centre on the issue of confidence and skill in singing from both teachers and pupils, individually and in groups, recognising and rewarding quality in singing, and the sustainability of externally funded initiatives as pupils move through their schooling and particularly from primary to secondary school. Good-quality support from specialists and external organisations can facilitate good practice in schools, but it seems to be important to integrate singing into children's wider musical learning and development within the curriculum, in the extended curriculum and beyond school in order to help sustain a lifelong interest in singing.

Strengthening music provision in early childhood education: a collaborative self-development approach to music mentoring for generalist teachers

“…Similarly, Swain and Bodkin-Allen (2017) showed that "gaining some knowledge of singing techniques [leads] to a sense of empowerment" in early childhood teachers (109). Research has shown that music mentoring by music specialists helps teachers acquire discipline-specific knowledge and teaching strategies (Draves and Koops 2011;Schmidt 2008) and builds their confidence (Davis 2016;Lamont et al 2012).…”

Teaching Music from the Perspective of First, Second and Third Grade Students of Primary School

“…Singing is an activity that has always been present in music teaching because singing is the most elemental, spontaneous, and natural way of expressing a person in music. As such, singing has given an important mark in the history of music teaching, and good experiences through singing in school are essential for a lifelong interest in music (Lamont et al, 2012;Pitts, 2009;Radočaj-Jerković, 2017;Spruce, 2002;Vidulin, & Terzić, 2011).…”

The whole class ensemble tuition programme in English schools – a brief introduction

“…Alongside learning to play an instrument, WCET programmes draw on a range of other music learning and performing activities, including clapping and rhythm games, movement, composing and listening to music. An important component of WCET programmes is singing, with the majority of programmes involving singing in some form (Lamont, Daubney, & Spruce, 2012). Some WCET programmes also involve learning to read from music notation, either staff notation, or graphic notation, or other forms.…”