The effects of a series of concentrations of ethylene (10, 20, 40, to 10,240 nl,'i) on elongation, diameter, and geotropism of the stems and roots of etiolated seedlings of Pisuin sativum L., Arachis hypogea L., Phaseolus vulgaris L., and Gossypiurn hirsutum L. were measured or observed. Of the 24 possible responses, 4 were unaffected at the concentrations used, 5 were affected slightly, and the remaining responses exhibited a 14-fold range of apparent half-maximum concentration dependencies (i.e. 95 nl/l for the effect on pea epicotyl geotropism to 1350 nl/l for the promotion of cotton hypocotyl diameter
MATERIALS AND METHODSIt has been reported that a number of different effects of ethylene have similar concentration dependencies and thus possibly the same primary binding site (2, 4). Further, they observed that a known metal binder, carbon monoxide, replaces ethylene in all its actions at a concentration of several hundred nl/ 1, and that competition between CO2 and ethylene has been established for essentially all actions of ethylene. From these observations it has been suggested that the primary binding site for ethylene action in plants is a metal-containing receptor having a limited access of approach with a Km of 6 X 10'" M (2, 4).There is sufficient published evidence to raise questions about the universality of these conclusions, especially regarding the single concentration dependency. It was noted by the earliest workers that different plant species varied in their sensitivity to ethylene (6,7,11,12 Seeds of peas (Pislim sativumn L., cv. Alaska) and beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L., cv. Burpee's Stringless Green Pod) were imbibed for 6 hr in aerated distilled H20 at 25 C, and seeds of peanuts (Arachis hypogea L., Spanish type, cv. Starr) and cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L., cv. Stoneville 213) were similarly imbibed for 1 hr. The seeds were then placed between moistened layers of white paper toweling which were sandwiched between layers of 1.25-cm thick, open celled urethane foam which had been washed thoroughly with distilled HP and had been drained. A set of seven such layers (with 15 seeds/layer) was held upright in a 30 cm x 10 cm X 25 cm black, opaque plastic container, which was placed in a dark germination cabinet at 25 C. Each container of seeds was supplied with a flow of 8 1/hr of humidified air which had been passed through a 60 cm X 6 cm diameter column of vermiculite and celite (4: 1 v/v) moistened with a saturated solution of potassium permanganate to remove all traces (<2.0 nl/l) of unsaturated hydrocarbons.After a specified number of days the seedlings were transferred to the treatment chambers. The chambers consisted of two 30.5 x 45.7 cm sheets of glass separated by a 1.25-cm thick rubber gasket (which was glued just inside the perimeter of the back sheet of glass). The back sheet of glass was attached to a plywood backing and the front sheet was held in place by a frame which was bolted to the plywood back.