Should community health workers offer support healthcare services to survivors of sexual violence? a systematic review

Abstract

BackgroundSexual violence is widespread, yet relatively few survivors receive healthcare or complete treatment. In low and middle-income countries, community health workers (CHWs) have the potential to provide support services to large numbers of survivors. The aim of this review was to document the role of CHWs in sexual violence services. We aimed to: 1) describe existing models of CHWs services including characteristics of CHWs, services delivered and populations served; 2) explore acceptability of CHWs’ services to survivors and feasibility of delivering such services; and 3) document the benefits and challenges of CHW-provided sexual violence services.MethodsQuantitative and qualitative studies reporting on CHWs and other community-level paraprofessional volunteer services for sexual violence were eligible for inclusion. CHWs and sexual violence were defined according to WHO criteria. The review was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. Quality of included studies was assessed using two quality assessment tools for quantitative, and, the methodology checklist by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence for qualitative studies. Data were extracted and analysed separately for quantitative and qualitative studies and results integrated using a framework approach.ResultsSeven studies conducted in six countries (Democratic Republic of Congo, Rwanda, Burma, United States of America, Scotland, Israel) met the inclusion criteria. Different models of care had diverse CHWs roles including awareness creation, identifying, educating and building relationships with survivors, psychosocial support and follow up. Although sociocultural factors may influence CHWs’ performance and willingness of survivors to use their services, studies often did not report on CHWs characteristics. Few studies assessed acceptability of CHWs’ to survivors or feasibility of delivery of services. However, participants mentioned a range of benefits including decreased incidence of violence, CHWs being trusted, approachable, non-judgmental and compassionate. Challenges identified were high workload, confidentiality issues and community norms influencing performance.ConclusionsThere is a dearth of research on CHWs services for sexual violence. Findings suggest that involving CHWs may be beneficial, but potential challenges and harms related to CHW-provided services exist. No different models of CHW-provided care have been robustly evaluated for effects on patient outcomes. Further research to establish survivors’ views on these services, and, their effectiveness is desperately needed.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12914-017-0137-z) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Should female community health volunteers (FCHVs) facilitate a response to gender-based violence (GBV)? A mixed methods exploratory study in Mangalsen, Nepal

“…Community members and leaders viewed them as individuals that women can trust to speak to about their GBV experiences. These overall findings are consistent with research and documentation, albeit limited, from other countries that CHWs can play a positive role in responding to GBV (Gatuguta et al, 2017;National Health Systems Resource Centre, 2011).…”

“…Stories of FCHVs leading their communities to abandon menstrual isolation, impose fines on excessive alcohol use, and not marry off their daughters early clearly demonstrate the role that FCHVs can play as agents of change. Similar findings on the positive role community health workers and volunteers can play in preventing GBV have been documented in other settings (Gatuguta et al, 2017;Ved et al, 2019). Further capacity building on gender transformative dialogues and community mobilisation can enhance this work.…”

A qualitative needs assessment of human trafficking in Ethiopia: recommendations for a comprehensive, coordinated response

“…For instance, participants noted that health extension workers in Ethiopia could be promoting information about the consequences of trafficking during their interaction with community members. This type of intervention would require minimal training and would engage a group that is already trusted by the community, as has been done with a mental health intervention in rural Ethiopia [43]; however, there is the potential that this might overburden health extension workers as was suggested in a review of community health workers providing services to survivors of sexual violence [44]. Integrative rather than additive solutions would be ideal.…”

An exploration of gender-based violence in eastern Myanmar in the context of political transition: findings from a qualitative sexual and reproductive health assessment

“…Indeed, studies have since explored the potentials, as well as remaining gaps, for the community-based provision of care for survivors of sexual violence. 48 Continued support for community-based SRH services that include medical and psychosocial care for survivors of GBV would be expected to increase availability, accessibility, and quality of SRH services in remote villages and contribute to overall health systems strengthening. Village-level systemsespecially those that support women and women's groupsshould be leveraged and expanded to protect women and girls in Myanmar.…”