Purpose: To improve cover crops as rotational partners, intraspecies variation for cover cropping traits such as nutrient mobilization, carbon deposition, and beneficial microbial recruitment must be identified. The majority of research on cover crops has focused on interspecies comparisons for cover cropping variation with minimal research investigating intraspecies variation. Methods: To address if variation of cover cropping traits is present within a cover cropping species, we grew 15 diverse accessions (four modern cultivars, three landraces, eight wild accessions) of pea in an organic setting. We measured various cover cropping traits such as nutrient mobilization, soil organic matter deposition, microbial recruitment, and quantified the effect of pea accession on the growth and yield of a subsequently planted corn crop. Results: We found that domestication history and genotype of pea had a significant effect on soil properties: C%, N%, manganese, magnesium, sodium, calcium, and effective CEC, and the yield of the subsequent corn crop. Additionally, no variation for prokaryotic recruitment (alpha and beta diversity) was observed within pea, however we did observe significant variation for fungal recruitment (alpha and beta diversity) due to domestication and accession. In conclusion, our results revealed the presence of intraspecies variation for cover cropping traits which, may have impacted the rotational values of pea accessions. Conclusions: Our results demonstrate that cover crops can be improved as rotational partners to ultimately boost crop yields in sustainable agroecosystems.