“…As we mentioned before, the loss of compactness for equations (1.1) may be produced not only by the concentration phenomena but also by the vanishing phenomena. In the literature, in order to exclude the vanishing phenomena, one can introduce the coercive potential (see [40,39,20]), or apply some symmetrization argument (see [9,8,6,2,15,34,28]). However, for our bi-harmonic equation (2.1), the symmetrization argument fails, since the nonlinearity f (t) in Theorem 2.2 needn't be an odd function.…”