Let α ∈ (0, 1), K ≥ 1, and d = 2 1+αK 1+K . Given a compact set E ⊂ C, it is known that if H d (E) = 0 then E is removable for α-Hölder continuous K-quasiregular mappings in the plane. The sharpness of the index d is shown with the construction, for any t > d, of a set E of Hausdorff dimension dim(E) = t which is not removable. In this paper, we improve this result and construct compact nonremovable sets E such that 0 < H d (E) < ∞. For the proof, we give a precise planar K-quasiconformal mapping whose Hölder exponent is strictly bigger than 1 K , and that exhibits extremal distortion properties.