This chapter focuses on the curation of cognitive niches understood as the curation of eco-cognitive chances: as chances can be faked, it seems intuitive to think that the inhibition of chance-faking contexts is a good activity of chance curation. Yet, could this activity sometimes be counterproductive? The question will be answered positively considering the case of bullshit as a case of fake chances, but also as a fertile ground for learning and developing intuitions. Ultimately, this chapter will argue that the peculiar context, that is the cognitive niche supporting the (potentially) fake chances, is the discriminating factor: indeed, a rich cognitive niche may benefit from certain kind of fake chances-which should therefore not be inhibited-whereas a poorer niche might not benefit from this situation, and therefore the preclusion of fake chances is an act of chance curation in those contexts.
IntroductionMy research did not focus on the biological arguments in favor of niche construction theory, but rather took it as a given and elaborated on a number of related issues that had been disregarded so far, mainly related to the management of cognitive niches and the underlying cognitive dynamics. It seems therefore proper to commence with the analysis of a phenomenon that is strictly connected with the management of cognitive niches, that is chance curation.Providing an introduction to cognitive niche theory, I stressed the relevance of two strictly related notions: chances and affordances, denoting niche construction as the activity of selecting the best ecological (and cultural) chances, that is those able to resonate with the agent's ecological, cognitive and cultural endowments, and thus become affordances-an affordance is in fact a relationship that is situated in a nexus between the ecological (external) dimension and the individual (cognitive) one.Parts of this chapter were originally published in L. Magnani, T. Bertolotti (2013). Selecting chance curation strategies: Is chance curation related to the richness of a cognitive niche?