Shapeshifting attachment: Exploring multi‐dimensional people–place bonds in place‐based citizen science

Abstract

Research on citizen science programmes has highlighted that they can foster science content and knowledge gain, enhance pro‐environmental behaviour and cultivate civic action among participants. Especially in the case of place‐based citizen science, which requires hands‐on repeated activity in an out‐of‐door setting through a scientific lens, evidence suggests that some of these outcomes may be linked to the unique people–place relationships and interactions afforded by such programmes. Even still, studies that empirically examine the influence of place on citizen science participant and programme outcomes are scant. This is due, in part, to the methodological challenges involved in interrogating complex aspects of a person's sense of place—aspects like place attachment—the emotional bonds between people and place. Here, an adapted three‐dimensional model of place attachment is proposed as a theoretical framework from which place‐based citizen science experiences and outcomes might be empirically examined in depth. The model, which posits personal, social and natural environment dimensions of place attachment is contextualized with research findings from the US‐based Coastal Observation and Seabird Survey Team (COASST) citizen science programme. Data from COASST suggest that participants do exhibit place attachment in all three dimensions of attachment, categorized within seven unique constructs, although questions remain regarding the unique intensity, make‐up (shape) and scale (spatial, social and nature‐science) of individual‐level attachment along the three central dimensions. Critically, more research is needed to investigate whether the unique place attachment ‘profile’ of participants is a function of personal, social or programmatic variables pre‐ and post‐programme participation. To encourage further scholarship on potential links between the experiences, exposures and programme components of place‐based citizen science and the place attachment profiles of participants, this paper includes a brief review of the research opportunities presented by the adapted three‐dimensional place attachment model discussed. Advancing this line of inquiry is an important component of broader efforts to understand how sense of place is altered via place‐based citizen science and whether or not that is linked to specific programme outputs or participant outcomes in science knowledge, ecological understanding and civic engagement. A free Plain Language Summary can be found within the Supporting Information of this article.

The STEM Enhancement in Earth Science “Mosquito Mappers” Virtual Internship: Outcomes of Place-Based Engagement with Citizen Science

“…Citizen science programs bring place-based education into informal learning (National Research Council, 2009). "Sense of place" has been described as the emotional, generative interaction between a person and a place, a sense which is emphasized and reified by experiences with place-based citizen science (Haywood 2014;Newman et al, 2017;Haywood et al, 2021). Evaluation of the Mosquito Mappers research internship demonstrated that the local citizen science fieldwork successfully used a sense-of-place pedagogy to motivate students.…”

Cold-Water Recreational Diving Experiences: The Case of Kelp Forests

“…These experiences are typical of memorable embodiment experiences in wildlife tourism (and not exclusively diving) [38]. The divers' narratives often revolved around personal and environmental contexts which contribute to place attachment, with emphasis on place dependence, place identity, nature bonding and environment bonding [39].…”

Towards ecological science for all by all

“…An under-researched area of citizen science, and more widely environmental stewardship, is the emotional bond between a person and a place, termed 'place attachment' (PAT). Haywood et al (2021) delineate a revised three-dimensional model of PAT for citizen science (after Raymond et al, 2010) and apply it to the COASST program. The three dimensions comprise personal, community and natural environment components, with seven major constructs across them.…”

“…Haywood et al. (2021) delineate a revised three‐dimensional model of PAT for citizen science (after Raymond et al., 2010) and apply it to the COASST program. The three dimensions comprise personal, community and natural environment components, with seven major constructs across them.…”

“…The three dimensions comprise personal, community and natural environment components, with seven major constructs across them. Through the analysis of interviewee responses, Haywood et al (2021) demonstrate that the participants exhibit PAT in all three dimensions and show how the PAT profile of an individual may change over time, with important implications for sustained engagement. These findings also reflect the difficulty in measuring, but undoubtedly important, motivations for citizen science (Tiago, Gouveia, et al, 2017).…”