Several Fe chalcogenide superconductors without hole pockets at the Fermi level display high temperature superconductivity, in apparent contradiction to naive spin fluctuation pairing arguments. Recently, scanning tunneling microscopy measurements have measured the influence of impurities on some of these materials, and claimed that non-magnetic impurities do not create in-gap states, leading to the conclusion that the gap must be s++, i.e. conventional s wave with no gap sign change. Here we critique this argument, and give various ways sign-changing gaps can be consistent with the absence of such bound states. In particular, we calculate the bound states for an s± system with a hole pocket below the Fermi level, and show that the nonmagnetic impurity bound state energy generically tracks the gap edge Emin in the system, thereby rendering it unobservable. A failure to observe a bound state in the case of a nonmagnetic impurity can therefore not be used as an argument to exclude sign-changing pairing states.Introduction -Superconductivity in the Fe-based superconductors[1] is thought to be controlled by local Coulomb interactions that give rise to repulsive effective interactions between band electrons [2][3][4]. In contrast to other materials classes where similar unconventional pairing mechanisms are at work, the Fe-based systems have a Fermi surface consisting of several small pockets around high symmetry points in the Brillouin zone. Pair scattering between Γ-centered hole pockets and M -centered electron pockets, was proposed early on as a plausible mechanism, with interpocket repulsion enhanced over intrapocket by electronic spin fluctuations. Somewhat later, new materials subfamilies were discovered (chiefly the FeSe intercalates [5][6][7] and monolayer FeSe on SrTiO 3 (STO) [8]), where doubt was cast on this particular pairing mechanism because of angle-resolved photoemission (ARPES) measurements that showed that the hole bands were not present at the Fermi surface, but instead had band maxima 50-100meV below ("incipient" bands).