Service delivery in Kenyan district hospitals – what can we learn from literature on mid-level managers?

Abstract

BackgroundThere is a growing emphasis on the need to tackle inadequate human resources for health (HRH) as an essential part of strengthening health systems; but the focus is mostly on macro-level issues, such as training, recruitment, skill mix and distribution. Few attempts have been made to understand the capability of health workers, their motivation and other structural and organizational aspects of systems that influence workforce performance. We have examined literature on the roles of mid-level managers to help us understand how they might influence service delivery quality in Kenyan hospitals. In the Kenyan hospital settings, these are roles that head of departments who are also clinical or nursing service providers might play.MethodsA computerized search strategy was run in Pub Med, Cochrane Library, Directory of Open Access Journals Social Science Research Network, Eldis, Google Scholar and Human Resources for Health web site databases using both free-text and MeSH terms from 1980 to 2011. In addition, citation searching from excluded and included articles was used and relevant unpublished literature systematically identified.Results and discussionA total of 23 articles were finally included in the review from over 7000 titles and abstracts initially identified. The most widely documented roles of mid-level managers were decision-making or problem-solving, strategist or negotiator and communicator. Others included being a therapist or motivator, goal setting or articulation and mentoring or coaching. In addition to these roles, we identified important personal attributes of a good manager, which included interpersonal skills, delegation and accountability, and honesty. The majority of studies included in the review concerned the roles that mid-level managers are expected to play in times of organizational change.ConclusionThis review highlights the possible significance of mid-level managers in achieving delivery of high-quality services in Kenyan public hospitals and strongly suggests that approaches to strengthen this level of management will be valuable. The findings from this review should also help inform empirical studies of the roles of mid-level managers in these settings.

Sowing the seeds of transformative practice to actualize women’s rights to respectful maternity care: reflections from Kenya using the consolidated framework for implementation research

“…Readiness for change is critical to ensure implementation of the maternity unit activities. Maternity unit activities confronted challenges similar to other studies in Africa, including inadequate knowledge and skills combined with broader health systems failures and low staffing [ 33 , 34 ]. Prior attention to macro issues related to workforce training, recruitment, retention and distribution recently shifted to human resources for health for strengthened health systems [ 35 ].…”

“…Prior attention to macro issues related to workforce training, recruitment, retention and distribution recently shifted to human resources for health for strengthened health systems [ 35 ]. Focus has turned to health workers capabilities, their motivations and other structural and organizational aspects of systems that influence and moderate workforce performance including leadership and supervision (mid-level management) and communication [ 34 – 36 ].…”

Healthcare service providers’ and facility administrators’ perspectives of the free maternal healthcare services policy in Malindi District, Kenya: a qualitative study

“…Another important aspect is the need to involve and communicate clearly with health workers and managers about the policy vision and goals, as well as about what and when actions will be taken [ 25 , 36 ]. It is recognized that leadership, supervision, information dissemination and communication are major mediators and moderators of the quality and effectiveness of health care [ 37 ]. It is also important to increase human resource strength in the facilities in order to address workload issues and improve quality of services that will attract and retain the high number of mothers seeking skilled delivery following the initiation of the program.…”

Influence of Job Description on Performance of Health Workers in Public Hospitals: A Case of Mbagathi Hospital, Nairobi City County

“…HWs' availability had an average score of 53.5%. Similarly, despite the fact that policies are in place to ensure the availability of HWs, less than half of HWs were present in their place of work and active at the time of survey [9,19,20]. Contrary, most respondents interviewed reported that the health providers were available in their place of work and that they were productive [16].…”